- The five reasons this keeps happening on every third channel you watch
- What happened when a client of mine tried one
- How the mechanics work, step by step
- The bit most creators won't tell you
- Is it worth it if you're a small channel or a small business?
- The smarter version of this, if you're going to do it anyway
- How to know if a giveaway is working for you
- Frequently asked questions
- Where to check the details
YouTube channels run giveaways to buy a fast spike in subscribers, comments and views, the numbers that sponsors price deals on and that help a video get shown to more people. A phone or a pair of headphones is a cheap way to get that spike, and the channel usually gains more from it than the winner gains from the prize.
It helps to separate two kinds. An engagement-bait giveaway makes entry depend on growth tasks (subscribe, comment, tag friends, follow on Instagram) and is built to move a metric. A milestone giveaway is a thank-you to people who already watch, often with entry open to existing viewers, and it moves loyalty more than numbers. Both can be generous; only the first is a growth tactic, and it comes with two measurable costs: a chunk of the new subscribers leave once the prize is gone, and the ones who stay often watch less of each video.
The five reasons this keeps happening on every third channel you watch
I've watched hundreds of these videos while researching client channels, and once you know what to look for, the pattern repeats almost every time. Strip away the excitement and there are only five real motives.
To see what those views are worth in ad revenue, run them through the free YouTube earnings calculator.
1. Sponsors pay on the numbers, not on the vibe
Brand deals get priced on subscriber count, average views, and engagement rate. YouTube doesn't publish sponsorship rates, and what a creator can charge varies widely by niche, audience country and average views, with finance, tech and business channels usually able to ask for more than entertainment channels of the same size. What doesn't vary is that a bigger, round subscriber number makes the conversation easier. A giveaway that pushes a channel across a round number, 10,000, 50,000, 100,000, changes what that creator can charge in the next negotiation. The giveaway itself might cost £200 in prizes. The subscriber jump it buys can raise the creator's day rate for the next twelve months.
2. YouTube's algorithm still rewards the wrong signals sometimes
Early comments, likes and shares are widely read as a sign that a video is worth showing to more people, though YouTube doesn't publish a fixed time window or a weighting for them. A giveaway video that asks people to "comment your entry below" or "tag three friends" is engineered to produce exactly that kind of burst. It works. Giveaway videos I've tracked for clients routinely pull three to five times the normal comment count of that channel's other uploads in the same week.
3. It's a funnel to somewhere else entirely
Read the entry rules on most giveaways and you'll notice the ask is never just "subscribe." It's subscribe here, follow on Instagram, join the newsletter, download the app. The giveaway isn't really about YouTube. YouTube is just the stage. The prize is the incentive to move an audience onto a list or a platform the creator owns, because a subscriber is rented from YouTube's algorithm and an email address is owned outright.
4. The giveaway is the sponsorship
A lot of what looks like generosity is a paid placement, and that has rules attached. A gaming chair brand doesn't just want a mention, it wants its product in someone's hands on camera with a "and I'm giving one away to you" line, because that line does more for consideration and desire than any ad read. The channel gets paid or gets free stock, the brand gets a warm product demo dressed as a gift, and the audience gets the entertainment of watching someone win.
If a brand supplied or paid for the prize, viewers have to be told. The US Federal Trade Commission's guidance for social media influencers says that if a brand gives you free or discounted products and you then mention its products, you should disclose it in simple, clear language that's hard to miss, and in the UK the ASA applies the same principle under the CAP Code. On YouTube that means saying it out loud in the video, putting it in the description, and ticking the paid promotion declaration in the video details when you upload.
5. Milestone goodwill
Some of it is exactly what it looks like on the surface. Hitting a million subscribers and giving something back is a genuine thank-you, and audiences can tell the difference between that and a cynical grab. It's the smallest of the five reasons in terms of frequency, but it's the one most viewers assume is the whole story.
What happened when a client of mine tried one
A fitness coach client I worked with, I'll call him Dan, had a YouTube channel stuck at around 6,000 subscribers for the best part of a year. He ran a giveaway for a £180 pair of AirPods Max. Entry rules were: subscribe, comment which workout you wanted to see next, and follow his Instagram.
The results in the first 48 hours were impressive on paper. He gained 1,140 new subscribers and 380 comments on a channel that normally got maybe 15 comments a video. His Instagram gained 290 followers in the same window.
Then the real picture showed up. Three weeks later, his subscriber count had dropped by roughly 400, meaning over a third of the giveaway subscribers unsubscribed once the prize was awarded and the excitement passed. His average view duration on the videos after the giveaway fell from 4 minutes 10 seconds to 2 minutes 50 seconds, because the new audience had signed up for a prize, not for his content. YouTube's algorithm noticed the drop in watch time and his next three uploads got roughly 30% fewer impressions than his pre-giveaway baseline.
He got a bump on paper and a dent in the metric that decides who sees his videos next. That's the trade nobody puts in the video description.
How the mechanics work, step by step
Almost every giveaway video follows the same production formula, whether it's a small creator or a channel with two million subscribers:
- Announce a prize with real retail value, usually something visual and desirable, a phone, a console, a trip, cash.
- Set entry conditions that double as growth tasks: subscribe, comment, like, follow on a second platform.
- Give a short entry window, usually 24 to 72 hours, to create urgency and cluster the engagement into a burst the algorithm notices.
- Announce the winner in a follow-up video or livestream, which is a second piece of content built on the back of the first, at no extra production cost.
- Repeat every few months, timed around subscriber milestones, sponsor calendars, or slow content weeks.
What separates a giveaway that's fair from one that lands a creator in trouble is the paperwork behind it. In the UK, the ASA's guidance on prize draws sets out what a promoter has to do, and it even cites an upheld complaint about a YouTube promotion that asked viewers to like and subscribe for the chance to win 10,000 pounds, where the promoter couldn't show the prize had been awarded. Before you launch, have this in place:
- Written rules, linked from the description and available for the whole promotion: who can enter, which countries, minimum age, opening and closing date and time, how to enter, what the prize is, and how the winner will be told.
- A plain line saying the giveaway isn't sponsored, endorsed or run by YouTube.
- A random draw you can prove. The ASA expects a verifiably random computer process or a draw supervised by someone unconnected with the promotion, so record your screen while a comment picker runs, or film the draw with an independent witness.
- Delivery on time. The ASA guidance says winners should usually receive the prize within 30 days, and that promoters should make information about the winner available, ordinarily the surname and county of major prizewinners.
- A note of who pays shipping, import charges and any tax on the prize, so the winner isn't hit with a bill they didn't expect.
The commonest thing that goes wrong is impersonation. Within hours of a giveaway going live, fake accounts copying the channel's name and picture reply to commenters saying they've won and asking for card details or a "shipping fee". The fix is a pinned comment saying you'll only ever announce the winner in a video or on your own channel and will never ask for payment, plus a reminder in the winner video.
MrBeast built an entire channel identity on scaling this exact formula, with ever bigger prizes and stunts. The mechanics are the same ones Dan used for his AirPods giveaway. Only the zeros are different.
The bit most creators won't tell you
Giveaways buy attention, not trust, and the two aren't the same thing even though they look identical in a subscriber count. A person who subscribes to win a phone hasn't decided they like your content. They've decided they like phones. Once the prize is gone, so is most of that audience, and the ones who stay tend to be lower-engagement subscribers who skew a channel's overall watch time downward for months.
YouTube has spam and deceptive practices policies and a separate contest policy in its Help Centre, and "subscribe to win" style asks sit close to the line those policies draw around artificially inflating engagement. Read the current wording before you launch rather than relying on what other channels get away with, because plenty of channels run these exact phrases every week and enforcement is patchy. Brands and creators both know this, and most of them run the giveaway anyway, because a short-term reach spike and a stronger rate card next quarter matters more to the business than a slightly softer average view duration that most sponsors never check closely enough to notice. Dan's numbers show the trade in one line: a 180 pound prize bought 1,140 subscribers, kept about 740 of them, and cost him nearly a third of his average view duration.
While you're here, take a look at this explainer on what channel pronouns are on YouTube.
Is it worth it if you're a small channel or a small business?
It depends on what you're optimising for, and this is where I see business owners make the wrong call most often. If you're chasing a sponsorship deal that's priced on raw subscriber count, a giveaway can move the number that matters to that negotiation. If you're trying to build a channel that sells a service, a course, or a product, a giveaway full of prize hunters can actively hurt you, because it dilutes the audience you need to convert.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Work out the price per subscriber you keep, not the price per subscriber you gain. With Dan's figures: 1,140 gained minus roughly 400 lost leaves about 740 kept, so the 180 pound prize cost about 24p per retained subscriber. That looks cheap until you set it against a fall in average view duration from 4 minutes 10 seconds to 2 minutes 50 seconds, which hurt the reach of every video he posted after it. For a channel that sells a service, I'd skip the engagement-bait version entirely and run a niche prize for existing viewers instead.
A rough cost breakdown from the giveaways I've helped clients plan:
- Small prize (£50 to £250, a gadget or gift card): typically 200 to 1,500 new subscribers on a channel with an existing base of a few thousand, with 25% to 40% unsubscribing within a month.
- Mid prize (£500 to £2,000, often sponsor-funded): can double a channel's weekly views for that upload and the next two, with a smaller drop-off if the entry requirement includes watching a full video rather than just commenting.
- Milestone giveaways tied to hitting 100k or 1 million subscribers: weaker growth effect but noticeably stronger comment sentiment and loyalty, because the audience reads it as a thank-you rather than a hook.
If your goal is raw reach for a sponsorship pitch, the maths can work. If you're studying which channels pull the biggest view counts, you'll notice most of them aren't running giveaways every week, they're running consistency. That's worth sitting with before you plan one.
The smarter version of this, if you're going to do it anyway
I'm not against giveaways as a tactic, I'm against running them without knowing what you're buying. If you run a small business channel rather than a personality-led one, the mechanics that work in wider marketing apply here too. There's a good breakdown of how contests can grow a business without turning into a pure vanity-metric exercise, and a companion piece on running giveaways with an actual commercial goal behind them rather than just a subscriber count target.
A few adjustments make a real difference to the quality of who enters:
- Make the entry require something related to your niche, not just a subscribe button, so the prize filters for interest rather than greed. A cooking channel giving away kitchen knives attracts people who cook. A cooking channel giving away an iPhone attracts everyone who wants a free phone.
- Route the entry through your email list or a landing page you own, so the growth doesn't evaporate the moment YouTube's algorithm decides to show your channel to fewer people that month.
- Track view duration and comment quality for the four weeks after the giveaway, not just the subscriber count on day one. That's the number that tells you whether you bought an audience or bought a spike.
If you're building a channel with limited time and no production budget, giveaways aren't even the highest-use move most of the time. There's more return in the basics covered in growing a channel quickly with limited resources, things like upload consistency, thumbnail testing, and nailing the first fifteen seconds, none of which cost £180 in AirPods.
How to know if a giveaway is working for you
Vanity numbers lie. If you want the true read on whether a giveaway helped or hurt, look at watch time per subscriber before and after, not subscriber count alone. This is the same principle covered in more depth in the webinar on measuring what your social numbers mean, where the gap between reach and real business impact gets picked apart across every platform, YouTube included.
To find the numbers, open YouTube Studio, go to Analytics and click Advanced mode, then set the date range to the four weeks either side of the giveaway and compare subscribers gained, subscribers lost and average view duration. A simple check I use with clients: pull your average view duration for the four weeks before the giveaway and the four weeks after. If it drops by more than 15%, the giveaway brought in the wrong audience and cost you algorithmic favour for a while. If it holds steady or rises, you targeted the prize well and the new subscribers are sticking around for the content, not just the comment section.
Run Dan's figures through it: 4 minutes 10 seconds is 250 seconds and 2 minutes 50 seconds is 170 seconds, a drop of 80 seconds, or 32%. That's more than double the 15% line, which is why his next uploads struggled.
If you want a reality check on how small a channel can be and still have an audience worth serving, this look at the channels with the lowest subscribers on youtube is worth a read.
And for how crowded the platform is before you try to stand out with a prize, see cuantos canales de youtube existen.
If you want the numbers, here's channels with over 100k subs on YouTube and what it means for you.
Frequently asked questions
Is it allowed to run a giveaway on YouTube?
Yes, but you're responsible for the rules and for running it legally, not YouTube. Publish clear terms, say the giveaway isn't run by YouTube, avoid misleading entry asks, and read YouTube's current contest and spam policies before you launch. If you're in the UK, the ASA's prize draw guidance applies too.
How do YouTubers pick giveaway winners?
Most use a random method shown on screen, such as a comment picker run while recording, or numbered entries drawn in front of a witness, and then announce the winner in a follow-up video or livestream. Keep the recording, because it's your evidence the draw was fair.
Do I have to disclose a sponsored giveaway?
Yes. If a brand supplied or paid for the prize, say so clearly in the video and the description and tick the paid promotion declaration when you upload. The FTC in the US and the ASA in the UK both expect the relationship to be obvious to viewers.
Do giveaway subscribers watch your videos afterwards?
Often fewer of them do. In the client example above, roughly 400 of 1,140 new subscribers left within three weeks and average view duration fell by about a third, so judge a giveaway on retention and watch time, not the day-one count.
Where to check the details
Run a business, a brand or a blog? I feature tools, products and expert guest posts for an audience of 15,000. See how it works