- Why this is messier than it looks
- Method one: browser-based converter sites
- Method two: VLC Media Player
- Method three: screen and audio recording
- Instagram's extra layer of difficulty
- A number worth knowing: file size and quality trade-offs
- What to do with the audio once you've got it
- The uncomfortable bit most guides skip
- Frequently asked questions
The short version: you can pull audio out of a YouTube or Instagram video for free using browser-based converters, desktop tools like VLC, or built-in screen recording, but the method you choose depends on whether you own the content, how long the clip is, and whether you need video-free audio or just want to listen without staring at a screen. There's no single "best" free tool because the platforms keep shutting the popular ones down.
Why this is messier than it looks
Every "best free YouTube to MP3 converter" listicle makes this sound like a solved problem. It isn't. YouTube and Instagram both actively work against third-party download tools because it threatens their ad revenue and their terms of service explicitly ban downloading content without permission, unless there's a download button they've built themselves. That's why half the converter sites that ranked well two years ago are gone, broken, or quietly swapped for something dodgier.
So before the "how," a quick reality check: if the video isn't yours, converting it to audio for anything beyond personal, private use (like listening to your own recorded webinar on a run) sits in a legal grey zone at best. Platforms can and do take down accounts for repeated scraping. If you're building a business around repurposing other people's video into podcast clips, that's the bit nobody wants to say out loud, but it's true.
A worked example to make this concrete
Say you run a small coaching business and you recorded a 40-minute YouTube live Q&A with your own audience last month. You want the audio as an MP3 so you can turn it into a podcast episode without re-recording anything. This is a clean, no-grey-area use case because it's your own content. Here's roughly how that goes:
- Open the YouTube video and copy its URL.
- Paste it into a reputable browser-based converter (search "youtube to mp3" and pick one without a pile of pop-up ads, that's usually your first red flag sign of a dodgy site).
- Select MP3 as the output format and 128kbps or 192kbps quality, 192kbps if you want it crisp enough for a podcast platform.
- Download the file, which for a 40-minute video is typically 35 to 55MB depending on bitrate.
- Drop it into free editing software like Audacity to trim the first two minutes of "can everyone hear me OK" chat.
Total time, maybe 10 minutes, zero cost. That's the whole appeal of this method and why so many small podcasters and course creators use it for their own repurposed content.
Method one: browser-based converter sites
These are the quickest route and need no software install. You paste a link, pick a format, download. The catch is that many of them are funded by ads, some sketchy, so stick to ones that don't ask you to install a browser extension or run anything executable. If a site asks you to download a ".exe" file to convert a video, close the tab.
These tools work fine for YouTube because video URLs are public. Instagram is trickier because most Reels and posts sit behind account walls or at least require a direct post URL, and Instagram changes its page structure often enough that converter sites break constantly. Expect to try two or three different tools before one works on a given day.
Method two: VLC Media Player
This one is completely free, open source, and doesn't rely on a website staying online. VLC can open a network stream directly from a URL and let you save it, or you can download the video first (using a separate free downloader) and then convert locally.
- Open VLC, go to Media, then Convert/Save.
- Add the video file or paste a network URL.
- Choose Convert, select an audio-only profile such as MP3 or OGG.
- Pick a destination file and hit Start.
This is slower and clunkier than a website, but it never shows you a pop-up ad and it works offline once you have the video file. Good for anyone nervous about random converter sites, especially after reading the paragraph above about dodgy executables.
Method three: screen and audio recording
If a video won't convert cleanly through any tool, there's a blunt fallback: play it and record your computer's internal audio with free software like Audacity (using "stereo mix" or a loopback input) or OBS Studio set to audio-only output. It's not elegant, you're essentially recording a recording, but it works on anything that plays, including Instagram Stories and Reels that have no download option at all.
Quality takes a small hit, usually a few dB of extra noise floor, but for a voice-only clip like a podcast snippet or a voiceover reference, most listeners won't notice.
Instagram's extra layer of difficulty
Instagram doesn't want you downloading anything, full stop. There's no built-in save-to-device for most video content, and the mobile app blocks right-click saving entirely. Third-party Instagram downloader sites exist, and some let you grab a Reel's video file which you can then run through VLC or an online MP3 extractor, but they change constantly because Meta updates its page code to break them on purpose.
If you're trying to pull audio off a trending Reel because you want to reuse the sound, don't bother converting it at all. Instagram's own "Use Audio" button on a Reel lets you attach that exact sound to your own post legally, which is faster and avoids the entire file-conversion headache. If what you want is free music rather than someone else's copyrighted track, it's worth looking at free background music for Reels instead of extracting someone's Instagram audio in the first place.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
A number worth knowing: file size and quality trade-offs
MP3 at 128kbps gives you roughly 1MB per minute of audio, so a 10-minute clip is about 10MB. Bump that to 320kbps and you're closer to 2.4MB per minute, noticeably better quality for music but overkill for spoken word. For most repurposing jobs, voiceovers, podcast audio, webinar recordings, 128 to 192kbps is plenty and keeps file sizes manageable for uploading to podcast hosts or sending over email.
What to do with the audio once you've got it
This is where the actual value sits, not in the conversion itself but in what you build from it. A converted audio file can become a podcast episode, a transcript for a blog post, a voiceover reference, or even a melody line if you're trying to recreate a tune, in which case you'd want something more specialised than a basic converter, which is where tools covered in best audio to MIDI converters by job come in if you're pulling musical notation rather than just a listenable file.
If the whole reason you're doing this is to build a side income repurposing content, it's worth stepping back and asking whether clip-flipping other people's videos is really the business model, because platforms are tightening enforcement every year. There are steadier, less legally fiddly routes to earning online, and some of the ways to make money online from home apply just as well outside India if you swap the specific gig platforms mentioned.
The uncomfortable bit most guides skip
Here's what doesn't get said enough: the audio you pull from someone else's YouTube video or Instagram Reel is still their intellectual property, and "I converted it for free" has nothing to do with whether you're allowed to use it. Free doesn't mean permitted. If you're building any kind of audience, newsletter, or paid product around repackaged audio from other creators, you're one copyright claim away from losing the account you built it on. If you're wondering whether that kind of repurposing even pays, it's worth comparing it to what creators earn directly, like the figures in how much Instagram pays for 100K followers, because often the maths favours making your own content rather than converting someone else's.
The safest free workflow, free of legal risk, is converting your own uploaded content: your webinars, your Lives, your client testimonials you have permission to use, your course videos. Everything else is borrowed risk dressed up as a free tool.
Frequently asked questions
Is it legal to convert a YouTube video to MP3 for free?
Converting your own uploaded video is fine. Converting someone else's video without permission breaches YouTube's terms of service even if the tool itself is free and doesn't cost you anything, so stick to content you own or have explicit permission to use.
What's the best free tool to convert Instagram video to audio?
There isn't a stable single answer because Instagram actively breaks third-party downloader sites. VLC Media Player combined with a separately downloaded video file tends to be the most reliable free option since it doesn't depend on a website staying online.
Does converting a video to audio reduce the quality?
Yes, slightly, especially if you choose a low bitrate like 96kbps. For spoken content such as podcasts or voiceovers, 128 to 192kbps is a solid free balance between file size and clarity.
Can I legally use Instagram Reel audio in my own post?
Yes, if you use Instagram's own "Use Audio" button on the Reel rather than downloading and re-uploading the sound file yourself. That's the legitimate route and skips the conversion process entirely.
Run a business, a brand or a blog? I feature tools, products and expert guest posts for an audience of 15,000. See how it works