Choose Apify if you want a ready-made scraper for a specific site, like building your own in JavaScript or Python, or want to publish tools for others. Choose Bright Data if your real problem is getting past blocking at scale, or you'd rather buy datasets or hand collection to a managed team. Neither wins outright; it depends on where your bottleneck sits.
Start with whatever's stopping you today. If it's that you don't have a scraper for the site you need, that points one way. If you've got scrapers but they keep getting blocked, that points the other. And if you don't want to run scrapers at all, there's a third answer. Most of this comparison falls out of that one honest look at your bottleneck.
Verdict first, detail after
Go with Apify when you want a ready scraper for TikTok, Google Maps, Instagram or a similar site, when your developers like writing their own crawlers, or when you'd like to publish tools and earn from them. Go with Bright Data when blocking, CAPTCHAs and scale are the hard part, or when you'd rather receive datasets and managed collection than build anything. I'd pick on your bottleneck, not on which brand feels bigger.
An app store versus the pipework underneath
The easiest way to picture the difference is this. The first vendor is close to an app store for scrapers. Its Store holds what the vendor says is 113,000+ ready-to-run tools, called Actors, built by the company and by its community. You find one for the site you need, run it in its cloud, and get your data. Or you build and publish your own.
The second vendor started from proxy infrastructure and has built products upward from there. That's why its site talks about IPs, unblocking and delivered datasets, while the other talks about Actors people have published. The vendor says it runs 400M+ proxy IPs across 195 countries and serves 50,000+ customers.
There's one more detail that matters if you hate lock-in. The store-first platform maintains Crawlee, an open-source scraping and crawling library, plus an SDK and CLI. So you can write your crawler on Crawlee, run it in their cloud, and still take the code elsewhere later. Nothing on the infrastructure provider's site points to an open-source library; it's a hosted service.
The differences in one grid
| Topic | Apify | Bright Data |
|---|---|---|
| Core model | Store of pre-built Actors, or build your own | Scraper APIs, Unlocker API, proxies, datasets and managed acquisition |
| Open source | Maintains Crawlee, plus SDK and CLI | None shown; hosted service |
| Proxies and unblocking | A rotating-proxy product as one part of the platform | Core line: residential, ISP and datacenter networks, plus an Unlocker API for blocks and CAPTCHAs |
| Ready-made data | You run community or official Actors yourself | Sells datasets and data feeds directly |
| Earning from your code | Developers publish Actors and earn from them | Partner program and Startup Program; no developer payout scheme shown |
| Done-for-you | Mostly self-serve, with a contact-sales route | Managed data acquisition and retail insights services |
| AI agents | Copy setup for AI and an MCP route | Its own MCP, Agent Browser and Search and Extract |
| Getting started | Free plan stated | Free trial stated |
If you write your own crawlers
Developers tend to feel at home on the store-first platform. You've got Crawlee, an SDK, a CLI, and a cloud to run things in. You can start from someone else's Actor and fork your own version. And if you build something useful, you can publish it and earn from other people's runs.
The infrastructure provider suits developers in a different way. It's less about writing the crawler and more about giving your crawler a clean route to the page, through proxies and the Unlocker API.
If blocking is your problem
This is where the infrastructure provider earns its place. Proxies aren't a side product there, they're the base of the business: residential, ISP and datacenter networks, plus an API built to deal with blocks and CAPTCHAs. If your scrapers work fine on small runs and fall over at volume, that's the problem it's designed around. The store-first platform does offer rotating proxies, but it's one part of a wider platform, not the main event.
If you'd rather not scrape at all
Plenty of business owners don't want a scraper. They want a spreadsheet of data. The infrastructure provider sells datasets and data feeds directly, and lists managed data acquisition and retail insights as services, so a team can do the collection for you. On the store-first side, data comes from running Actors yourself. It's self-serve first, with a contact-sales route for larger jobs.
Agents and AI workflows
Both now court AI builders. The store-first platform offers a copy-setup-for-AI option and an MCP route so agents can call Actors. The infrastructure provider lists its own MCP, an Agent Browser and a Search and Extract product for agents. On paper, both will plug into an agent stack. Which one fits better comes back to the same question: do your agents need a specific ready scraper, or a reliable way past blocking?
Other scraping options to weigh
If you're still weighing it up, these four come up in the same searches. Our page on other scraper platforms and Actor-style tools goes wider, and so does the guide to AI-ready crawling and extraction tools.
Zyte
Best for: Scrapy users wanting web data APIs, managed delivery and Scrapy Cloud hosting from the team that maintains Scrapy.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
ScraperAPI
Best for: One simple API call that handles rendering and retries, with structured endpoints for Amazon, Google and Walmart and an async queue of 50,000 jobs.
Oxylabs
Best for: Proxy networks plus a Web API for search and scraping aimed at AI agents from a large, established provider.
Octoparse
Best for: No-code, drag-and-drop scraping with templates for Google Maps, Amazon and more, and a managed cloud to run them.
Do you make web scraping or data collection tools? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this page.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.
Frequently asked questions
Is Apify or Bright Data better for beginners?
If you're not a developer, a ready-made Actor from the store is often the quickest start, because someone has already built the scraper for your site. If you'd rather not touch scrapers at all, buying a dataset from the infrastructure provider is simpler still.
Can I use my own code on these platforms?
Yes. The store-first platform lets you build and publish your own Actors, and its Crawlee library is open source, so your crawler code isn't locked in. The infrastructure provider is mainly a hosted service that your own scrapers connect to.
Which one is stronger on proxies?
Proxies are a core product line for the infrastructure provider, with residential, ISP and datacenter networks and an Unlocker API. The store-first platform offers rotating proxies as one part of its wider platform.
Can I buy data instead of scraping it?
On the infrastructure provider's side, yes: it sells datasets and data feeds, and offers managed data acquisition. On the store-first side, you get data by running Actors yourself.
Do both work with AI agents?
Both list an MCP route. The infrastructure provider also lists an Agent Browser and Search and Extract, while the store-first platform offers a copy-setup-for-AI option for its Actors.


