Asset 20 8 2
Does AI recommend your business? Run the free check →

Join 15,000 business owners, marketers and entrepreneurs. The Sunday newsletter you'll be annoyed only arrives once a week.

Article

Best AI Customer Support QA Tools: 9 for Scoring Tickets

Customer support QA tools review and score your team's tickets, chats and calls against a scorecard, so you stop judging a whole team on the few conversations a lead has time to read. Start with the kind built for your main channel, voice or text, and check its scores against your own reviewers before you trust a single number.

Buy the wrong QA tool and you end up with a dashboard full of scores nobody on the support floor believes. That's worse than the spreadsheet you had before, because now the numbers look official. This page is about one job: reviewing and grading support conversations for quality, turning what the review finds into coaching, and seeing patterns across the queue. It isn't about bots that answer customers for you; for those, my guide to AI customer service tools is the better read. A few of the products below sell both, and untangling the two is where the trouble starts.

Five traps in buying support QA software

Buying an agent platform when you wanted a reviewer. A few of the homepages on this list lead with AI agents and voice bots, with quality review further down the page. That's not a reason to skip them, but it's a reason to be clear about what you're buying. Before a demo, write down the one sentence you need, something like "we want to review and score our conversations", and ask to see that screen first. If the call spends twenty minutes on a voice bot, you've learned where the product's attention sits.

Trusting an AI score you never calibrated. An automatic score is only useful if it agrees with the people who'd have scored the conversation by hand. Take a batch your best reviewers have already graded, have it run through the tool, and compare line by line. Where the tool and your lead disagree, read the conversation yourself. Sometimes the tool's right and your reviewer was being kind. Sometimes it's rewarding a polite tone and missing that the answer given to the customer was wrong.

Letting the vendor's scorecard become yours. A ready-made scorecard is tempting because it works on day one. Your quality bar isn't generic, though: the refund rule agents keep bending, the tone a premium brand expects, the line a regulated business must read out on a call. Check you can write your own criteria, weight them and mark some as an automatic fail. Then check whether the AI can grade those custom criteria or only the stock ones, by asking to see a question you wrote scored live.

Scoring everything and coaching nothing. Reviewing the whole queue is a headline promise on this list; EvaluAgent's homepage puts it as QA on all of your conversations without a bigger team. That's useful, but a score on each chat doesn't make anyone better at the job. What changes behaviour is a team lead sitting down with an agent over three real conversations. So ask how a flagged conversation becomes a coaching session: can a lead assign it, comment on it, and see whether that agent's next fortnight looks different? If coaching lives in a separate tool, count the time spent moving between the two.

Forgetting the people being scored. Your agents will read these scores. If they can't see why a conversation lost points, I'd expect the trust to go quickly, and with it the point of the exercise. Look for the agent's own view of a review, the reason attached to each lost point, and a way to dispute a score that a human then settles. A QA programme agents see as fair gets used; one they see as surveillance gets gamed.

Nine tools that review and score support conversations

EvaluAgent

Call centre QA and performance improvement software, built around reviewing all of your conversations rather than a small sample.

Zendesk QA

Zendesk's own AI-powered quality assurance product, for monitoring and reviewing support conversations so issues can be picked up and addressed proactively.

MaestroQA

Now carrying the Rippit name, it presents itself as a growth data platform for teams and AI agents, pulling evidence out of customer conversations.

Level AI

A customer experience platform that scores customer interactions and turns conversations into insights, with AI voice agents sold alongside the scoring.

Insight7

Call intelligence with QA scorecards for reviewing calls handled by both AI and human agents, plus AI voice agents for automated calls and training.

Observe.AI

One CX platform built around purpose-built AI agents, where conversations handled by AI and by people are both evaluated for performance.

Convin

An AI agent platform for customer conversations whose Conversation Intelligence Agent reviews interactions and flags potential compliance issues.

Loris

Conversation intelligence that analyses customer conversations to surface friction points and feature gaps, so it leans towards product insight more than agent grading.

Cresta

Sold as an AI operating system for customer experience, working inside live conversations, across many conversations at once and in back-office tasks.

Work with me

Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?

I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.

Sampling a slice or reviewing the lot

Manual QA means a reviewer picks a handful of tickets per agent each week and grades them. It's slow and the sample is tiny, but people trust it, because a person read the whole thing. AI review flips that around: the software reads the queue and humans check the software. Both have a failure built in. A small manual sample can miss the one conversation that matters, and a fully automated score can be confidently off on the conversations that are hardest to judge.

The middle path is the one I'd start with. Let the AI read the whole queue to choose what humans should review: the angry customer, the long silence, the refund that went through with no reason given. Your reviewers stop grading random tickets and start grading the ones worth their time. Ask each vendor whether the tool can do that routing, not just produce a score, and whether you can set the rules for what gets pulled.

Calls, chats and email are different jobs

Voice QA needs a transcript before anything else, so the transcript's quality sets the ceiling on everything after it. Ask to upload a handful of your own recordings, with your callers' accents, your product names and your hold music, and read the transcript before you look at a single score. If voice is most of your operation, my list of AI call centre software covers the wider platforms these tools sit inside.

Chat and email are already text, so the question there is different: does the tool join a thread across channels? A customer who emailed, then chatted, then rang is one problem, and you want it reviewed as one, not as three unrelated conversations with three scores. Check how the tool connects to your helpdesk too, because a QA product that can't see your tags, macros and ticket history will be grading without context.

There's a third job hiding in this category. Some of these products sell themselves as conversation intelligence, mining conversations for friction points and feature gaps rather than grading agents. That's valuable, and it's not the same purchase. If finding patterns for the product team is the main goal, my guide to conversation intelligence software is the closer fit.

A one-hour scorecard test

Pull twenty closed conversations from last month: five your team rates as excellent, five as poor and ten ordinary ones. Strip nothing out; the messy ones are the point. Write your scorecard as five to eight plain questions, the ones your leads already use, and mark one as an automatic fail.

Ask the vendor to run the twenty through the tool with you on the call. Then look at three things. Does it rank the five poor conversations at the bottom? For the two conversations where it disagrees most with your team, does its reasoning make sense when you read the chat? And when you open the agent's view, can someone who's never seen the product work out in a minute why a conversation lost points? If all three hold up, you've got a candidate. If the vendor won't run your own conversations before you sign, that tells you something too.

What it costs to run

Zendesk QA is sold as an add-on to a Zendesk Support or Suite plan, so its cost sits on top of your helpdesk plan, which matters if you're weighing it against a stand-alone tool. For the others, go to each pricing page or ask on the sales call, and get the quote in writing for the number of agents you'll score and the channels you'll connect.

The software is only part of the cost. Someone has to build the scorecard, calibrate the AI against your reviewers, and keep doing it when your policies change. Budget a few hours a month of a senior lead's time for that, at least at the start, or the scores will drift away from what your team means by quality.

Where I'd start

For a team on one helpdesk handling chat and email, I'd start with QA that sits inside or connects tightly to that helpdesk, because fewer exports means fewer gaps. For a voice-first contact centre, I'd go for a call QA product and judge it first on the transcripts of your own recordings. For a team that mainly wants to know why customers get in touch, conversation intelligence is the better buy than a scorecard tool. And for a team that also wants AI to answer customers, an all-in-one customer experience platform can make sense, as long as the QA part passes the one-hour test above on its own merits.

Do you make AI QA tools for support teams? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.

Whichever type you lean towards, run the test before the contract, and keep a human reviewer in the loop for the first quarter. The tool earns more trust from your agents once they've seen a person agree with it.

Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.

Published and maintained by the Lilach Bullock team, covering marketing, AI and business growth.
Your buyers are asking AI who to use. Does it say you?

See for free whether ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google name you, and get the plan to become the answer.

Check my AI visibility →
Sundays only

Get the Sunday newsletter.

One email a week. AI experiments, marketing tactics, and the workflows Lilach is building right now in her own business.

Subscribe free

Let’s get your marketing running on AI.

Book a free 30-minute call

We figure out what you need, where AI fits in, and what working together would look like.

Book the call →

Or take the 30-second calculator

You’ll see the hours and the money quietly leaking out of your week, and the three workflows worth building first.

Take the calculator →

Or grab the free AI resource library

Prompt packs, templates, checklists, and swipe files. The exact tools I build for paying clients. Yours, free.

Get the library →
Keep reading

More from the blog.