Asset 20 8 2
Does AI recommend your business? Run the free check →

Join 15,000 business owners, marketers and entrepreneurs. The Sunday newsletter you'll be annoyed only arrives once a week.

Article

Should You Italicise Newsletter Titles? A Quick Style Guide for Email Marketers

If you are skim reading
Yes, in most cases: Chicago and MLA treat a newsletter's name like a magazine title and italicise it in running text, while AP style writes it in plain capitals with no italics and no quotation marks.

Yes, in most cases: Chicago and MLA treat a newsletter's name like a magazine title and italicise it in running text, while AP style writes it in plain capitals with no italics and no quotation marks. In email subject lines, preheaders and plain-text versions, where italics can't show, put the name in quotation marks instead. Italics render unreliably across email clients, so the grammar rule sometimes has to bend to what Outlook shows your reader.

Once your formatting is settled, the posts that mention your newsletter still need to earn the read, and this checklist of What a Good Blog Post Should Always Include covers the rest.

Should newsletter titles be italicized? The rule

Newsletter titles get italicised in running text, the same way you'd italicise The New York Times or Wired. So if you write "I read about it in Morning Brew" or "our own newsletter, The Weekly Experiment, covers this every Friday," the newsletter name is italicised because it's the name of a recurring publication, not a one-off article or a casual mention. The general convention, as summaries of italic type usage set out, is that works which stand by themselves, periodicals included, are italicised, while works that sit inside a larger work, such as articles and episodes, go in quotation marks.

That's the rule in a single sentence. Most people asking this question already suspected as much and just wanted confirmation before they sent 40,000 emails with the wrong formatting. Fair enough. But the rule has edge cases, and the edge cases are where email marketing specifically diverges from print or web style, which is the part worth reading for.

What the major style guides say

I checked three of them because I didn't want to give you my opinion dressed up as a rule.

  • AP Style (used by most news outlets and a lot of B2B marketing teams) doesn't italicise at all, technically, because AP was built for print wire copy where italics didn't transmit reliably. It uses quotation marks around titles of books, songs, TV shows, poems and works of art, but not around the names of magazines and newspapers, as Purdue University's Online Writing Lab summarises the rule. A newsletter is a periodical, so in AP copy it reads Morning Brew: capitals, no quotes, no italics. If your company follows AP style for blog content, that's how your newsletter name should appear.
  • Chicago Manual of Style (the one most publishers, book editors, and long-form content teams default to) treats newsletters as periodicals and italicises them, same category as magazines and journals. Purdue OWL's Chicago style formatting guide sets out the rule: book and periodical titles are italicised, while article and chapter titles go in double quotation marks.
  • MLA, used mostly in academic writing, also italicises periodical and publication titles, which includes newsletters. Purdue OWL's MLA general format guide says to italicise the titles of longer works, the group periodicals belong to.

Side by side, with a single issue included:

GuideNewsletter nameA single issue or article
ChicagoItalicsQuotation marks
MLAItalicsQuotation marks
APCapitals, no quotes or italicsQuotation marks, as for AP's other composition titles such as books and songs
APAItalics (APA Style's italics page lists periodical titles)No italics: APA keeps them for stand-alone works and periodicals

So the honest answer is: it depends which style guide your brand has quietly picked, whether anyone told you or not. If nobody at your company has ever said "we follow AP" or "we follow Chicago," you don't have a house style, you have a habit, and habits drift. I'd bet money that if you pulled the last 20 blog posts from most mid-sized marketing teams, you'd find newsletter titles italicised in some, quoted in others, and in plain text in the rest. Here's how the same sentence looks under each treatment:

  • Chicago or MLA: The tip came from The Weekly Experiment last Friday.
  • AP: The tip came from The Weekly Experiment last Friday.
  • Quotation marks, the fallback for subject lines and plain text: The tip came from "The Weekly Experiment" last Friday.
  • One issue inside the newsletter, Chicago style: The tip came from "Why We Dropped Our Welcome Email," last Friday's issue of The Weekly Experiment.

That last line is the rule people miss most: the issue title is a piece inside a larger publication, so it takes quotation marks, and the newsletter name around it keeps its italics.

A short story about my own newsletter's name

When I relaunched my weekly newsletter a couple of years back, I called it The Weekly Experiment, and for about four months I wrote it four different ways across my own content: sometimes italicised, sometimes in quotes, sometimes just capitalised with no formatting at all. Nobody complained. Not one subscriber, not one client, not one colleague. It took me finding my own inconsistency in a content audit, three blog posts in a row, three different treatments, to fix it.

That taught me something useful: readers don't care about this nearly as much as writers do. What they notice is whether your subject line made them open the email and whether the content inside was worth their four minutes. Formatting consistency matters for your own credibility and for anyone auditing your content later (an editor, a new hire, future you), but it is not a subscriber-facing problem in the way we sometimes convince ourselves it is. I still fixed it, because sloppy formatting compounds across hundreds of posts and starts to look like carelessness in aggregate, even if no single instance gets noticed.

The practical rule I now give clients

When I'm working with a marketing team on their content style (this comes up more than you'd think, right alongside questions like whether webinar titles should be italicised, which follows the same logic), I give them a four-step test:

  1. Pick one style guide and write it down. AP or Chicago, doesn't matter which, but put it in your brand's content guidelines document so the next writer doesn't have to guess.
  2. Apply it to your own newsletter name first. If you're Chicago style, italicise it every time it appears in a blog post, guest post, or case study. If you're AP, write it in capitals with no quotes or italics, the way AP treats magazine and newspaper names.
  3. Check how it behaves in the actual send. This is the step almost every style guide skips, because style guides were written for print and web, not for HTML email rendering across 30 different clients.
  4. Use quotation marks in subject lines and preheaders, always. Subject lines don't support styled formatting reliably across inboxes, and italics in a subject line reads as a rendering error to most readers anyway, not as a stylistic choice.

Why italics can quietly break inside an actual email

This is the bit that most grammar-focused advice on this topic never mentions, because it's written by copyeditors, not by people who've built and sent an HTML email. Italics in the body of an email are usually fine in Gmail, Apple Mail, and most modern clients that render HTML. But:

  • Plain-text versions of your email (which some subscribers still receive, either by choice or because their client defaults to it) strip italics entirely. Your carefully italicised newsletter name just becomes plain text, no formatting at all.
  • Some older or stripped-down email clients, and Outlook desktop versions that render email through Word, can handle emphasis tags inconsistently, especially inside tables, which is how most email templates are built under the hood.
  • Screen readers may announce italics differently, or not at all, depending on the client and the reader's settings, so accessibility-focused teams sometimes avoid relying on italics to carry meaning at all, and use bold or quotation marks instead, which read more reliably out loud.

A five-minute test settles it for your own template. Send a test of your next issue to yourself, then open it in Gmail on the web, in Outlook desktop if you or your readers use it, and on your phone. Look for the newsletter name in each and check it still reads as a name. Then open the plain-text version in your email platform (usually a separate plain-text tab or setting in the editor) and check the name there. If your platform lets you edit the plain-text version, put the name in quotation marks, since italics can't exist there.

None of this means don't bother. It means don't treat the italics as load-bearing. If your newsletter's name needs italics to be understood as a title (rather than, say, a random word in a sentence), you've probably got a naming problem, not a formatting problem. A newsletter called "The Weekly Experiment" is legible with or without italics. A newsletter with a name that could be mistaken for a regular sentence, something like "Grow" or "Focus," benefits from the italics doing some disambiguation work, and that's exactly the case where inconsistent rendering across clients becomes a real (if small) problem.

Quotation marks vs italics vs bold vs nothing

Here's how the four options behave and when each one makes sense:

Work with me

Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?

I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.

  • Italics: correct under Chicago and MLA, reads as "this is a title," but unreliable in plain-text emails and some older clients.
  • Quotation marks: not AP's rule for publication names (AP saves quotes for works such as books and songs), but the standard fallback when italics aren't available, and it renders identically everywhere because it's just punctuation, no formatting dependency at all. This is the safest choice for anything email-specific.
  • Bold: not grammatically standard for titles under any major style guide, but it's what a lot of email marketers use anyway because it renders reliably and draws the eye, which matters more to them than being technically correct. I see this constantly in marketing blog content and I understand why, even though it's not "right."
  • No formatting, just capitalisation: correct under AP for a publication name, weaker under Chicago and MLA, and the most common in the wild, because most people writing about their own newsletter never look up the rule in the first place.

If you write in APA, which a lot of academic and business reports use, APA Style's own page on italics lists titles of periodicals among the things to italicise, so a newsletter name is italic in APA too. And wherever italics aren't available at all, quotation marks are the usual substitute, with underscores (_The Weekly Experiment_) as an informal option some people use in plain text.

My pick for most email-led businesses is a split rule: italics wherever formatting works, quotation marks wherever it doesn't. Paste this into your style guide as it stands:

Newsletter names: italic in web and blog copy; quotation marks in email subject lines, preheaders and plain-text versions; issue titles always in quotation marks.

If your team follows AP, swap the first part for plain capitals and keep the rest.

Where this fits into your wider content style

If you're building out proper brand guidelines for your marketing content (and if you're running any kind of consistent newsletter operation, you should be, because it saves every future writer and freelancer hours of guessing), the newsletter title question is a small piece of a much bigger decision about how you handle titles generally: webinar names, ebook titles, podcast episode names, course titles. Get the underlying logic right once (recurring publication equals periodical treatment, one-off piece equals quotation marks) and you can apply it everywhere without relitigating it every time you sit down to write. It's the same reasoning that applies to the webinar title question, which is really the same rule wearing a different hat.

And if you're still building out the newsletter itself, the formatting question is one of the smaller decisions on the list. Subject line, send time, segmentation, list hygiene, and actual content value all move the needle far more than whether your newsletter's name has a squiggle under it. I'd rather see a marketer spend an extra hour on their welcome sequence than on this. If you want the fuller picture of what drives newsletter performance, our complete guide to email marketing covers the parts that move open rates and revenue, which this doesn't.

A quick checklist before you standardise

  • Pick AP or Chicago and write the choice down somewhere your whole team can see it.
  • Apply italics (Chicago) or plain capitals with no quotes (AP) to your own newsletter name in every blog post, guest post, and media mention going forward.
  • Never italicise in subject lines or preheader text.
  • Check your plain-text email version and confirm the newsletter name still reads clearly without formatting.
  • Don't rewrite five years of back catalogue content to fix this. Fix it going forward and move on.

If you'd like to put this into practice by writing for another publication, the tech news page explains how to pitch.

Frequently asked questions

Do I italicise an individual newsletter issue title?

No. Under the usual convention an issue is a piece inside a larger publication, so the issue title goes in quotation marks and the newsletter name stays italic: "Why We Dropped Our Welcome Email," an issue of The Weekly Experiment.

Do I italicise the newsletter name when it's on its own in a header?

Not usually. A logo, masthead or email header is design, not running text, so style it however your brand looks best. The italics rule applies when the name appears inside a sentence.

What do I do when italics aren't available?

Use quotation marks, the usual substitute when formatting isn't supported, as in a subject line, preheader or plain-text email. Under AP, plain capitals with no quotes are also correct for a publication name.

What about newsletter names that include a subtitle, like "The Weekly Experiment: Marketing Notes"?

Treat the whole thing as one title and apply the same formatting rule to the entire phrase, colon and subtitle included, rather than italicising or quoting only part of the name.

Run a business, a brand or a blog? I feature tools, products and expert guest posts for an audience of 15,000. See how it works

Published and maintained by the Lilach Bullock team, covering marketing, AI and business growth.
Your buyers are asking AI who to use. Does it say you?

See for free whether ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google name you, and get the plan to become the answer.

Check my AI visibility →
Sundays only

Get the Sunday newsletter.

One email a week. AI experiments, marketing tactics, and the workflows Lilach is building right now in her own business.

Subscribe free

Let’s get your marketing running on AI.

Book a free 30-minute call

We figure out what you need, where AI fits in, and what working together would look like.

Book the call →

Or take the 30-second calculator

You’ll see the hours and the money quietly leaking out of your week, and the three workflows worth building first.

Take the calculator →

Or grab the free AI resource library

Prompt packs, templates, checklists, and swipe files. The exact tools I build for paying clients. Yours, free.

Get the library →
Keep reading

More from the blog.