The short version: you can create Instagram Story Highlights covers on your phone using Canva or the Instagram Story editor itself, saving each cover at 1080x1920 pixels and cropping it down to the circular 108x108 thumbnail Instagram shows. You do not need a designer or a paid app, but you do need to batch them all in one sitting, because doing them one at a time as you go is how most profiles end up with a mismatched mess.
What a Highlights cover is (and why most people get the sizing wrong)
Your Highlight cover is the small circle that sits under your bio, above your grid. It is not a separate upload slot where you design a tiny circle from scratch. Instagram takes a frame from whatever photo, video or image you add to that Highlight and crops it into a circle for you. That means your source image needs to be designed as a full vertical frame, not a tiny round logo, because Instagram is doing the cropping, not you.
This trips people up constantly. Someone will design a perfect little circular badge in Canva, upload it as the cover, and Instagram crops it into an off-centre oval because it is still treating the image as a 9:16 vertical story, not a circle. The fix is simple once you know it: design the full 1080x1920 canvas with your icon or text centred in the middle third, so whatever Instagram crops out still lands in the right place.
Step-by-step: creating covers on your phone
Here is the version that works, done entirely on a phone, no laptop needed.
- Open Canva (free app) and search "Instagram Story" as your template size, which gives you the 1080x1920 canvas automatically.
- Pick a plain background colour or a soft texture rather than a busy photo. Solid colour backgrounds crop far more predictably than photos.
- Add one icon, one short word, or one simple line illustration dead centre. Keep it inside roughly the middle 60 percent of the canvas, since the edges get cropped off when Instagram makes the circle.
- Repeat this for every category you want a Highlight for: Reviews, FAQs, Behind the Scenes, whatever applies to you. Design all of them in one Canva project so the colours and fonts match.
- Download each one as a PNG, saved straight to your camera roll.
- Go to your profile, tap "New" under Highlights (or edit an existing one), select the cover image you just made, drag it so the centre of your icon sits in the middle of the crop circle, and save.
That is six steps, and if you are doing five or six Highlights, budget about 25 to 30 minutes total once you have your template built. The second batch you ever make will take half that time because you are reusing the same Canva project.
A worked example
Say you run a small skincare brand account with four Highlights: Reviews, Ingredients, Shipping, and FAQs. Instead of using four random product photos as covers (which is what most accounts do and why most Highlight rows look like a bag of mismatched sweets), you build one Canva project with a sage green background, a thin white outline icon for each category (a star for Reviews, a leaf for Ingredients, a box for Shipping, a question mark for FAQs), and the same font weight across all four words underneath each icon. Four downloads, four uploads, and your profile suddenly looks like it was designed on purpose rather than assembled in a panic five minutes before a launch.
The uncomfortable bit nobody tells you
Matching Highlight covers do not make your content better, and spending two hours perfecting a colour palette for six tiny circles is often procrastination dressed up as branding work. I have seen more energy go into Highlight cover design than into whatever is sitting inside those Highlights. If your FAQ Highlight is three stories old from 18 months ago, a beautiful cover icon is not fixing that. Covers are a five percent polish job. Do them in one sitting, make them consistent, and then spend the rest of your time on the content behind them, not the thumbnail in front.
Apps and tools that work on a phone
You have three realistic options:
- Canva (free tier): best for anyone who wants text, icons and brand colours without fiddling. Thousands of Instagram Highlight cover templates already sized correctly.
- Instagram's own Story editor: open a blank story, add a sticker or text on a solid background colour, screenshot or save it, then use that as your cover. No extra app needed, but less control over fonts.
- Unfold or VSCO: better if you want a more editorial, muted aesthetic rather than bold icons. Slightly steeper learning curve.
For most small businesses and solo creators, Canva wins simply because it is free and fast.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Where this fits with the rest of your Stories strategy
Covers are one small piece. Once they are sorted, the bigger wins come from how you manage the Highlights themselves, like knowing how to reorder your Highlights so your most relevant one sits first, or understanding how to delete a Highlight without deleting the underlying story when you want to retire a category without losing the content. It also helps to know how long Stories last and where they go before you decide what is worth saving into a Highlight in the first place.
If you are building out your profile more broadly, two other small details worth sorting while you are in there: adding a pronunciation guide to your Instagram name if people regularly mangle it, and knowing how to add photos to someone's Instagram Story mention if you are doing collaborative content. And if you want a quick batch of Story content to fill those Highlights, the Halloween Story ideas post has prompts that work well beyond the season too.
Common mistakes worth avoiding
- Using a photo of a face as a cover. Faces get cropped unpredictably and often end up half cut off.
- Making every cover a different colour because you grabbed whatever photo was handy. Pick one palette and stick to it across all covers.
- Forgetting that covers display at a tiny size on most phones, roughly the size of a fingertip. Thin text and fine detail simply disappear. Bold, simple icons survive the shrink; anything delicate does not.
- Rebuilding covers every few months out of boredom. Unless your branding has changed, leave them alone. Consistency over time is worth more than novelty.
Frequently asked questions
What size should Instagram Highlight covers be?
Design the source image at 1080x1920 pixels, the same as a standard Instagram Story, and centre your icon or text in the middle third of the canvas. Instagram automatically crops this down to the 108x108 pixel circle it displays on your profile.
Can I create Highlight covers without Canva?
Yes. You can open Instagram's own Story editor, add a sticker or text onto a plain coloured background, save it to your camera roll, and use that saved image as your cover. It is slower for matching a set, but it works with no extra app.
Why do my Highlight covers look cropped or off-centre?
This happens when the icon or text in your source image sits too close to the edges. Instagram crops a circle out of the middle of your image, so anything outside the central area gets cut off. Keep key elements centred and you avoid this.
How many Highlight covers should a profile have?
There is no fixed rule, but most active profiles settle on four to eight categories. More than that and the row becomes hard to scan on a phone screen, which defeats the point of having them.
Run a business, a brand or a blog? I feature tools, products and expert guest posts for an audience of 15,000. See how it works