Asset 20 8 2
Does AI recommend your business? Run the free check →

Join 15,000 business owners, marketers and entrepreneurs. The Sunday newsletter you'll be annoyed only arrives once a week.

Article

Following vs Followers on Instagram for New Users

If you are skim reading
The short version: followers are people who chose to see your posts, following is the list of accounts you chose to see.

The short version: followers are people who chose to see your posts, following is the list of accounts you chose to see. New users muddle the two because Instagram displays them side by side as if they're equally important, but they measure completely different things, and chasing the wrong one is the fastest way to waste your first few months on the app.

What each number means

Your followers count is the audience who tapped the follow button on your profile. Every one of them has said, in effect, "show me this account's posts." That's your reach. It's the number brands look at, the number that makes your bio feel credible, and the one most new users obsess over within the first week of setting up a profile.

Your following count is the opposite direction entirely. It's the list of accounts you've chosen to follow, which shapes your own feed. If you follow 800 accounts, Instagram has 800 potential sources to pull content from when it builds your home feed. This number says nothing about your popularity. It says something about your curation habits.

New users often treat these as a single combined score, something like a popularity index, and that's where the confusion starts. A profile with 2,000 followers and 2,000 following is not twice as impressive as one with 2,000 followers and 200 following. If anything, the second profile looks more intentional, because the owner hasn't followed everyone back out of politeness.

The follow-back ratio problem

Say you set up a new business account for a small candle shop. In week one you follow 300 accounts (suppliers, other candle makers, local shops, customers) hoping some follow back. By week four, 40 have followed back, so you're sitting at 40 followers and 300 following. Anyone who checks your profile sees that ratio instantly and reads it as "this account is trying too hard." A follower-to-following ratio under 1 reads as low credibility to anyone paying attention, including brands considering you for a collaboration.

Compare that to a second candle shop that followed 60 relevant accounts (its five best suppliers, ten local businesses, forty engaged customers) and ended up with 55 followers from genuine interest. Smaller numbers both ways, but a ratio close to 1 that reads as established rather than desperate.

Why following shapes what you see, not who sees you

This is the part most beginners skip past. Who you follow directly controls your feed, through engagement signals Instagram tracks constantly. If you follow 500 accounts but only engage with 30 of them, Instagram quietly deprioritises the other 470 and fills the gaps with suggested content instead. That's why new users often complain their feed is "full of stuff I didn't ask for" within a month of signing up, when really it's full of accounts they followed and then ignored.

If you want your feed to reflect the people you follow rather than Instagram's suggestions, you can switch it manually. There's a straightforward way to change the Instagram feed to following only, which strips out the algorithmic guesswork and shows posts purely from accounts you follow, in order. It's a setting most new users never find because Instagram doesn't surface it prominently, for the obvious reason that suggested content keeps you scrolling longer.

If suggested posts specifically are the problem, there's also a separate method for how to stop suggested posts on your Instagram feed, which is worth doing before you follow a single account, so your following list stays the one thing shaping what you see.

Chronological order changes the whole calculation

Once your feed is set to following only, the next decision is whether you want it chronological or algorithm-ranked. Instagram's default, even in following-only mode, still ranks posts by predicted interest rather than time posted. If you'd rather see posts in the order they were shared, there's a clear process to see posts in chronological order on Instagram. For new users this matters more than it sounds, because a bloated following list with no chronological control means older, more "relevant" posts from big accounts bury the smaller accounts you followed on purpose.

The uncomfortable bit about follower counts

Here's what most advice on this topic won't tell you plainly: a high follower count on a brand new account is almost always a vanity metric with no commercial weight behind it. If you've been active for three weeks and have 1,200 followers, the realistic breakdown is something like this: a chunk from follow-for-follow swaps that'll unfollow within a fortnight, a chunk of bot or low-quality accounts that never open the app again, and a small genuine core who'll see your posts. Brands and serious collaborators know this, which is why engagement rate (comments, saves, shares as a percentage of followers) has quietly overtaken raw follower count as the number that gets checked first in any partnership conversation. A profile with 600 followers and a 6% engagement rate will out-earn a profile with 6,000 followers and a 0.4% engagement rate, every time, in almost any niche.

So if you're building a new account purely to hit a follower milestone, you're optimising for a number that stops mattering the moment anyone looks closely. Better to follow fewer accounts deliberately, post consistently, and let followers accumulate as a side effect of being worth following.

A simple worked example for a new account

Say you run a small freelance graphic design business and you're starting an Instagram from scratch. Here's a realistic month-one approach that keeps the following/followers balance sane:

Work with me

Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?

I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.

  • Week 1: follow 20 to 30 accounts maximum. Pick actual peers, two or three potential clients, and a handful of design inspiration accounts you'll engage with.
  • Week 2: post three times, comment on five posts a day from accounts you follow, rather than following more new accounts.
  • Week 3: review who you followed. Unfollow anyone who's posted nothing useful or hasn't engaged back in any way. This typically trims 20 to 30% of an initial follow list.
  • Week 4: check your ratio. Aim for followers roughly equal to or above following. If you're following 60 and have 15 followers, slow down on following and focus entirely on posting quality content and commenting rather than adding more accounts.

By the end of month one, a disciplined new account following this pattern typically sits somewhere around 40 to 80 followers with a following list under 100, which is a far stronger foundation than 500 followers scraped together through mass-following tactics that collapse the moment you stop.

Privacy and control matter more than the numbers

New users also underestimate how much the following list affects who can contact you, not just what you see. If your account is public, anyone can message you regardless of whether you follow them, and new accounts attract a disproportionate amount of spam and unsolicited messages in the first few weeks simply because the algorithm flags you as new and active. It's worth knowing how to block Instagram message requests from strangers early on, before it becomes a daily annoyance.

On the flip side, once you've got a following list you trust, you can use Instagram's close friends feature to share more candidly with a smaller circle. Setting up a close friends list on Instagram is a good move once your following list has stabilised, because it separates "people I follow for professional reasons" from "people I want seeing my unfiltered posts."

One more thing worth flagging for business accounts specifically: a low-quality or newly flagged account can run into restrictions that have nothing to do with followers or following counts at all. If you've ever wondered why your account is restricted from going live, it's usually linked to community guideline flags rather than audience size, so don't assume a healthy follower number protects you from account-level restrictions.

What to prioritise as a new user

Stop checking your follower count daily. Check your following list weekly instead, because that's the one you control completely and the one that actively shapes your experience of the app. Followers will follow good content; they don't follow a good following-list strategy. Keep your following list lean, relevant, and reviewed monthly, and the followers side tends to sort itself out over a realistic three to six month period rather than a weekend.

Frequently asked questions

Is it bad to follow more people than follow you back?

It's not inherently bad, but a following count far higher than followers signals to anyone checking your profile that you're following for exposure rather than genuine interest, which can hurt credibility for business accounts specifically.

Does following more accounts help the algorithm show my content to more people?

No. Following accounts affects what appears in your own feed, not who sees your posts. Your reach depends on your followers' engagement and the content itself, not on how many accounts you follow.

Should a new business account follow back everyone who follows them?

Not automatically. Follow back relevant accounts (customers, partners, peers) but following every single follower regardless of relevance just inflates your following count without adding value to your feed or your credibility.

How many accounts should a new Instagram user follow in the first month?

Somewhere between 20 and 50 is sensible for most new users. It's enough to build a useful feed without diluting it with accounts you'll never engage with.

Run a business, a brand or a blog? I feature tools, products and expert guest posts for an audience of 15,000. See how it works

Published and maintained by the Lilach Bullock team, covering marketing, AI and business growth.
Your buyers are asking AI who to use. Does it say you?

See for free whether ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google name you, and get the plan to become the answer.

Check my AI visibility →
Sundays only

Get the Sunday newsletter.

One email a week. AI experiments, marketing tactics, and the workflows Lilach is building right now in her own business.

Subscribe free

Let’s get your marketing running on AI.

Book a free 30-minute call

We figure out what you need, where AI fits in, and what working together would look like.

Book the call →

Or take the 30-second calculator

You’ll see the hours and the money quietly leaking out of your week, and the three workflows worth building first.

Take the calculator →

Or grab the free AI resource library

Prompt packs, templates, checklists, and swipe files. The exact tools I build for paying clients. Yours, free.

Get the library →
Keep reading

More from the blog.