Recharge is the subscription commerce platform for a Shopify brand that wants a lower entry tier and a broad set of extras, from loyalty to analytics; Skio is the subscription platform for an established brand at scale that wants its migration handled and a team focused on cancel flows and SMS. Newer subscription lines should start with Recharge; brands already running at volume should get a Skio demo too.
On the scale tier, the headline monthly fee and the transaction fee read the same on both pricing pages. If you expected one to be the budget option and the other the premium one, that's the first surprise. The real differences sit around that matching tier: where you can start, how you pay, what costs extra and who moves your existing subscriptions across.
The short answer for a Shopify subscription brand
Launching subscriptions, or still proving that customers want them? Recharge is the one to try first. It has a Starter tier below Scale, with a try-for-free option, so a brand can test subscriptions without committing to the higher plan.
Already running a sizeable subscription programme, perhaps on Recharge, and looking for a team that'll do the move for you? Book a Skio demo. Skio says it handles migration for you, its Scale plan bundles a multi-step cancel flow builder and its own SMS tool, and its support team is described as ex-Shopify and ex-Recharge people.
If you're somewhere in between, the deciding questions are whether you need a cheaper entry tier, whether you'll pay annually and which add-ons you'll switch on. The rest of this page works through each.
Where Recharge has the edge
Recharge's home page says it's built for Shopify, and it covers subscriptions, loyalty, support and analytics, so a brand can keep more of its retention work in one place. Both apps are made for Shopify brands. Still deciding where the store itself should live? Settle that first with my guide to ecommerce platforms.
The Starter tier is the practical advantage. It comes with a try-for-free option, and its processing fee is a slightly higher percentage than on Scale, which is a fair trade while volumes are small. When the brand grows, Scale lowers that percentage and, on Recharge's pricing page, adds end-to-end migration support.
Recharge lists around a hundred prebuilt integrations, including Klaviyo, Gorgias and Avalara, and offers a JavaScript SDK and a Storefront API for brands that want a custom subscription experience. It also claims a high recovery rate on failed payments, quoting an up-to figure that's worth testing against your own data.
Where Skio has the edge
Skio says more than a thousand subscription brands run on it. Migration is part of the offer: it says it handles the move for you, and says it has moved fifty thousand-plus subscriptions.
Its Scale plan includes a multi-step cancel flow builder, so leaving runs through steps you design, and SkioSMS for subscription messages by text. Native integrations, webhooks and an API are listed on the same plan. Support is described as ex-Shopify and ex-Recharge people, which matters if your team wants someone who knows both systems.
Text messages make a neat side-by-side test. SkioSMS is part of the Scale plan. Recharge's Concierge SMS is billed per message on top. If your brand runs reorders, skips and reminders by text, that difference grows with every message sent, so count how many texts a typical customer gets in a month and price both routes before the platform fee distracts you.
Larger brands get a custom-priced Enterprise tier with volume pricing, and the sales route throughout is a demo rather than a self-serve sign-up. That suits a brand with enough volume to negotiate.
Same headline fee, different routes in
Both pricing pages show a Scale plan at the same monthly fee, with the same transaction fee: a percentage of each order plus a small fixed charge. So the headline price for a scale brand is identical. The differences are around the edges.
Recharge has a lower Starter tier, with a slightly higher percentage fee, and Skio's page shows no Starter tier at all. Skio's Scale figure assumes annual billing; pay monthly and its pricing page lists a higher monthly fee. And Skio's transaction fee is charged on orders with a subscription in them, so check how each platform treats one-off orders that pass through the same checkout.
What drives the bill
On both, the bill has two parts: a monthly platform fee and a per-transaction fee made up of a percentage plus a fixed amount per order. As your subscription revenue grows, the transaction fee becomes the bigger number, so a lower percentage on a higher tier can pay for itself sooner than the monthly fee suggests.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Add-ons come next. Recharge's Concierge SMS carries an extra per-message charge, and Skio's loyalty feature carries an additional charge too. Skio doesn't state a free trial or free route on its pricing page, so check the vendor's own pages or ask in the demo. Prices for every tier sit on each vendor's pricing page; read them alongside your own order numbers rather than on their own.
Moving subscriptions between them
Migration is where Skio leans in. Because it says it handles the move, a brand leaving Recharge should ask in the demo exactly which parts Skio does and which stay with your team. Its Scale plan lists native integrations, webhooks and an API, which helps reconnect the rest of your stack afterwards.
Going the other way, Recharge lists end-to-end migration support on its Scale plan, and its JavaScript SDK and Storefront API give a developer room to rebuild a custom customer portal. Whichever direction you take, map every live subscription product, discount and delivery interval first, check that payment details will carry across without customers re-entering them, and tell your customers before anything changes on their account.
Timing matters as much as tooling. I'd avoid moving in the weeks before a busy sales period, run a small batch of subscriptions through the new platform first and only move the rest once renewals on that batch have charged and shipped without a problem. Keep the old app installed until every customer has renewed at least once on the new one, so nobody is charged twice or not at all.
Limits on each side
Recharge's entry tier carries the higher percentage fee, so a fast-growing brand should work out when moving to Scale makes sense. Concierge SMS is an extra cost, and a broad feature set means more to configure.
Loyalty is extra. And the demo-led sales route means you won't be signing up on your own in an afternoon. Above Scale, Enterprise pricing is custom, so a large brand won't see its real number until it's negotiated.
An hour with one subscription product
Pick your best-selling repeat product and write down three numbers you already know: roughly how many subscription orders it would take in a month, the average order value and how often customers reorder.
Open Recharge's pricing page and work out the monthly platform fee plus the transaction fee on that month's orders for Starter and for Scale. Do the same on Skio's pricing page for Scale, paid annually and paid monthly. Then list the add-ons you'd switch on in the first quarter, such as SMS or loyalty, and add their charges.
Finish by starting Recharge's free trial on a test store and setting up that product as a subscription, and by booking a Skio demo where you ask them to show the same product with a cancel flow. You'll come away knowing which total is lower for your volume and which setup your team found easier to run. If the bigger goal is lifting order value rather than repeat orders, my guide to Shopify upsell apps covers that side of the store.
Take a short list into the Skio demo. Which parts of the migration does its team run, and which stay with yours? How do existing payment details move across? What happens to customers mid-cycle on the day you switch? Ask Recharge's team the same questions about its Scale migration support. The answers will tell you more about the next three months than any feature grid.
Do you make subscription apps for Shopify brands? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.


