If you want another service that takes sales tax and compliance off your hands the way Paddle does, look at the merchant of record platforms; if you'd rather stay the seller and pay less per sale, look at subscription billing software. Decide that first, then push one real product through two checkouts before you move a single customer.
Paddle describes itself as a merchant of record for SaaS and app sellers, handling billing, tax and compliance. That's a specific promise, and it's the thing people most often forget to check when they shop around. Three of the tools on this page are billing software, one is a creator storefront that has since become a merchant of record, and the rest sell on your behalf the way Paddle does.
Merchant of record or subscription billing: decide this first
With a merchant of record, the platform is legally the seller. Your customer's receipt names the platform, it works out and pays sales tax and VAT around the world, and it carries the compliance that comes with selling into lots of countries. You're paid out what's left after the fee.
Subscription billing software works the other way round. You stay the seller. The tool runs plans, invoices, upgrades and failed-payment recovery, but tax registrations and filings remain your job, and card processing is usually charged separately by whoever processes the payments.
Neither is better in the abstract. A solo founder selling a low-priced app to buyers in forty countries is usually far better off with a merchant of record. A company with a finance team and most of its revenue in one or two markets often finds billing software much cheaper and doesn't miss the hand-holding.
What changed in 2026
Two things are worth knowing before you shortlist. Lemon Squeezy's homepage now carries a banner headed '2026 Update: Lemon Squeezy + Stripe Managed Payments', so read that page yourself rather than relying on older reviews of how it works. And Polar changed its terms for organisations created from 27 May 2026: newer accounts start on a different rate from its early members, so a fee you saw quoted in a forum thread may not be the one you'd get.
A little further back, Gumroad became merchant of record for its sellers on 1 January 2025, which turned a simple creator storefront into something that also deals with sales tax. The pattern across the category is clear enough: the lines between storefront, billing tool and merchant of record are blurring, so check what each one does today.
What each model costs you
Merchant of record platforms in this space mostly charge between about 3.9% and 5% of each transaction plus 40 to 50 cents, with no monthly fee on their basic terms. Creator storefronts can run higher, up to around 10% plus 50 cents, and you're paying for simplicity. Billing software takes far less as a share of volume, typically under 1% and sometimes with a monthly platform fee, but card processing comes on top and tax stays yours. A few providers only quote on request.
Here's the sum that matters. On $10,000 of monthly sales at an average order of $25, that's 400 orders. At 5% plus 50 cents the fee is $700. At 3.9% plus 40 cents it's $550. Billing software at 0.7% is $70, but add card processing and the cost of registering and filing tax in your main markets before you call it the cheap option. And the fixed fee is what hurts low-priced products: on a $5 sale, 50 cents is a tenth of your price before any percentage is applied.
Read the small print too. Payout fees, dispute fees, refund fees and extra charges on certain payment methods all appear on these pricing pages, and on a busy month they add up.
Nine Paddle alternatives
Lemon Squeezy
A merchant of record for digital products and SaaS that shoulders tax compliance, now linked with Stripe Managed Payments according to its 2026 homepage update.
Polar
A developer-focused merchant of record offering subscriptions and usage-based billing, with global tax handled for software makers.
Creem
A newer payments platform for software and digital product sellers that takes care of taxes, payouts, affiliates and usage billing together.
Dodo Payments
Billing and payments for digital products with credit-based billing, usage metering and subscriptions, for teams who'd rather not build that plumbing themselves.
PayPro Global
A long-standing merchant of record for software, SaaS and video game sellers, covering global payments, sales tax, subscriptions and fraud prevention.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Gumroad
A simple storefront where creators sell digital products, courses and subscriptions, acting as merchant of record for its sellers since January 2025.
Stripe Billing
Subscription and usage-based billing run through APIs or the Stripe Dashboard, for teams happy to remain the seller of record.
Chargebee
Billing, pricing and revenue operations software covering subscription and usage-based models, aimed at SaaS companies with a finance function.
Recurly
Subscription management spanning plans, billing, failed-payment recovery and churn reporting, suited to established subscription businesses.
Push one product through two checkouts in an hour
Pricing pages and demos only tell you so much. An hour in test mode tells you the rest.
- Create the same product at the same price in two shortlisted tools, using their test or sandbox modes.
- Buy it as a customer from two places: your own country and somewhere you'd owe tax, such as an EU country. Check the tax line, the currency and who the receipt says sold it.
- Cancel, refund and upgrade the test subscription. Count the clicks and read the email your customer would receive.
- Open the payout and fee report and check the numbers match the pricing page.
- Ask support one real question, such as how existing subscribers are moved across, and time the reply.
The receipt is the giveaway. If it names the platform as the seller, you're on a merchant of record. If it names you, the tax is yours.
Before you move your subscribers
Moving new sales is easy. Moving people already paying you is where revenue leaks. Card details usually sit with your current provider, so ask both sides whether payment tokens can be transferred or whether customers will need to re-enter their cards. If it's the latter, some will drift away, so write the email that asks them with care and send it before the renewal date, not after.
Run new sign-ups on the new platform first, leave existing subscribers where they are for a billing cycle, and move them in batches once the first renewals go through cleanly. Keep your accountant in the loop as well: a merchant of record files the sales tax, but you still have income to report and books to close.
- Don't compare a merchant of record's percentage with billing software's percentage as if they cover the same work. One includes tax and card processing, the other usually includes neither.
- Don't ignore the fixed per-transaction fee on cheap products. It can matter more than the percentage.
- Don't trust a fee quoted in an old review. Several platforms here have changed their terms recently.
- Don't forget the payout side. Minimum payouts, payout fees and currencies all affect your cash flow.
What I'd choose, by type
A solo founder or tiny team selling software worldwide should start with a merchant of record built for SaaS, and compare one of the developer-focused newcomers with an established name. Creator selling and usage billing call for different tools: creators selling courses, templates or ebooks are well served by a creator storefront, accepting the higher fee for a shop that's ready in an afternoon, while products priced by consumption or credits need a platform with usage billing built in, which several of the newer merchants of record now offer.
A growing SaaS company with a finance team and revenue concentrated in a few countries should look at subscription billing software on top of its own processor, and register for tax itself. Software or game publishers who want a long-established partner and are happy to talk to sales will find the older merchants of record that price by quote a comfortable fit.
If you're still shaping what you sell, my list of digital products to sell as a solopreneur is a useful companion, and this piece on subscription billing software features helps if you're leaning towards the billing model.
Do you make payments, billing or merchant of record software? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.