The best Mailspring alternative comes down to your computer and your mailboxes. Want free and open source on any system? Choose an open-source desktop client. On a Mac with Gmail, a native app built for Gmail fits better, and teams sharing an inbox need a collaborative client.
Switching email clients sounds trivial until you've spent a weekend rebuilding signatures, filters and folders, only to find the new app chokes on your work account. That's the real cost of a wrong pick: not the licence, the lost hours. So rather than start with a list, start with a test.
A one-hour test to run on your top two
Mailspring is a desktop app for handling several mailboxes on a laptop, so the replacement has to do that job first and look nice second. Shortlist two apps from the list below, install both, and give each half an hour:
- Add every account you use, including the awkward one: the work mailbox, the old domain you still check, the shared address. If an account won't connect cleanly, stop there.
- Search for an email from two years ago by a word in the body, not the subject line. Time it. Slow search is the thing you'll curse every single day.
- Write a reply with your signature, an attachment and a quoted thread, then send it to yourself on your phone and look at how it arrives.
- Leave the app running for the rest of the hour and watch your laptop's fan and battery. Some desktop clients are heavier than the work they're doing.
- Set up one rule or filter, then check it fires on the next matching email. If filtering is clumsy, your inbox will drift back to chaos within a fortnight.
Whichever app passes all five wins, whatever the review sites say. If both pass, pick the one you enjoyed using. You'll open it dozens of times a day, and that counts for more than a feature you'll touch twice a year.
Clients that handle every mailbox you own
Thunderbird
The free, open-source pick, covering email, calendar and contacts on Windows, Linux and macOS alike.
Betterbird
Like Thunderbird but want more? This fine-tuned version adds extra features and bug fixes on top of the original.
eM Client
Windows and Mac users wanting calendar, contacts, tasks and chat inside the same desktop app as their email should try this one.
Mailbird
Gathers many email accounts into one desktop app on Windows or Mac, and leans on being quick, private and simple to use.
Mac specialists, team inboxes and a different idea of email
Mimestream
Made for Mac and built around Gmail, so it suits anyone whose mail lives entirely in Google and who wants a native app.
Airmail
An Apple-only mail client that runs across iPhone, iPad, Mac and Vision Pro, with custom actions for people who like to tinker.
MailMate
Keyboard purists on macOS should look here: an IMAP client with Markdown composing, smart mailboxes and extensive keyboard control.
Missive
When a team shares inboxes, this client lets colleagues work the same conversations together and turn emails into tasks.
HEY
Less a client than a whole email and calendar service from 37signals, with its own apps and a privacy-first inbox.
The choices that narrow it down
Your operating system. Several of the best apps here are Mac-only or Apple-only. If you work across a Windows desktop and a MacBook, rule those out at once and save yourself the trial.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
A client or a whole service. Most of these are clients: you point them at the mailboxes you already have and nothing about your address changes. One option here is different, a full email service with its own address and apps, which means moving where your email lives, not just which app opens it. That's a bigger decision and you should treat it as one.
Just you, or a team. A personal client is built for one person reading their own mail. A team inbox lets several people see, assign and discuss the same message, and it's priced for that. If you're the only one in your support inbox, you don't need it yet.
Gmail only, or a mix. If every account is Google, an app built just for Gmail is worth a look. If you've got a mix of providers, a general client that speaks standard IMAP is the safer bet.
Do you make desktop email clients or email apps? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
How these apps charge
Six of the nine publish a price on their own pricing pages this month, and almost no two charge the same way. You'll find yearly subscriptions, monthly ones, a plan billed every three months, a per-user fee for teams, and at least one one-time purchase. In round numbers, the personal subscriptions here come to about $40 to $100 a year, and the one-time licence is about $75. The two open-source clients and Airmail publish no price on the pages read for this list, and the team inbox charges per user, so add a seat for everyone who reads the shared mail.
The open-source route is where the free option sits. With the paid apps, the question isn't the headline price, it's what happens in year three: a subscription keeps billing, a one-time licence doesn't. If you keep apps for a long time, do that sum before you buy.
What changed in this corner of the market
Two moves are worth knowing about. Postbox's own site now says it's been acquired by eM Client, so if Postbox was on your shortlist, look at its new owner instead. And Mailbird's homepage says it's now free, with its pricing page limiting the free plan to one account, so check that limit against how many mailboxes you run.
Common mistakes when people switch
Deleting the old app before the new one has finished downloading your mail is the classic. Give the new client a day to sync everything, search for a few old messages to prove they're there, and only then remove the old one.
The second is forgetting the things that live inside the client rather than on the server: signatures, templates, local folders and rules. Copy them somewhere before you switch. The third is chasing features you won't use. A client with a built-in calendar, tasks and chat is lovely if you'll use them and clutter if you won't.
If you're weighing the open-source route, my list of Thunderbird alternatives goes deeper on that family, and for a Windows machine my round-up of email clients for Windows is the better starting point.
My pick by setup
On a Mac with only Gmail, go native and Gmail-first. On Windows or Linux, or a mix of systems, start with a free open-source client and only pay if it fails the hour-long test. If keyboard shortcuts are how you work, pick the Mac client built around them. If two or more people answer the same address, skip personal clients and choose a team inbox. And if you're tired of email itself, not just the app, that's when a whole new service is worth the upheaval.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.


