Asset 20 8 2
Does AI recommend your business? Run the free check →

Join 15,000 business owners, marketers and entrepreneurs. The Sunday newsletter you'll be annoyed only arrives once a week.

Article

Keyboard Maestro vs BetterTouchTool for Mac Power Users

Keyboard Maestro fits a Mac user who wants to build macros with conditions, loops and per-app groups, fired by hot keys, schedules or apps opening. BetterTouchTool fits a Mac user who wants trackpad gestures, mouse buttons, keyboard shortcuts, the menu bar or a Stream Deck to trigger chains of actions.

You've just done the same five clicks for the tenth time today: rename a file, move it, open the client folder, paste a line into an email. Somewhere around the tenth repeat, a Mac user starts looking for a way to hand that job to the computer, and two names come up again and again. Keyboard Maestro and BetterTouchTool both automate a Mac, both sell as one-off licences rather than subscriptions, and both have deep libraries of actions. They differ in what sets the automation off and how much logic sits inside it.

Macros on one side, gestures and inputs on the other

Keyboard Maestro, made by Stairways Software, runs macros built from hundreds of built-in actions, triggered by hot keys, schedules, applications and more. The actions include flow control, conditions and looping, so a macro can check what's on screen, branch and repeat. Macros live in Macro Groups that control when they're active, including per application, and those groups can appear as palettes, custom toolbars or menu bar items.

BetterTouchTool is a Mac utility for customising trackpad and mouse gestures, keyboard shortcuts, the menu bar and Stream Deck, with chainable actions for automation. Its home page cites more than six hundred built-in actions and more than six hundred triggers and inputs. It also offers Logitech mouse control with no extra drivers, and a licence unlocks the BTT Mobile companion app for iPhone and iPad.

So the starting question is simple: is the thing you want to automate a sequence of steps, or a gesture, click or button you want to give a new meaning? Keyboard Maestro is built around the first, BetterTouchTool around the second, and plenty of overlap sits in between.

Keyboard Maestro: the upside and the downside

The upside is depth of logic. Flow control, conditions and looping mean a single macro can handle a job with several decisions in it, such as acting differently depending on which app is in front. Per-application Macro Groups keep shortcuts from clashing, since a hot key can do one thing in your browser and something else in your editor. Palettes and custom toolbars give you a visible menu of macros when you'd rather click than remember shortcuts, and macros can sync with another Mac, with Macro Groups switched off per Mac where you don't want them.

The downside sits in how it's licensed and what it needs. A purchase covers one major version, with a paid upgrade for later major versions, so you'll pay again when you want the next one. It requires macOS High Sierra or later. And because it's macro-first, mapping a trackpad gesture or a mouse button isn't where it starts; you'll build that kind of shortcut in BetterTouchTool more directly.

BetterTouchTool: the upside and the downside

The upside is reach across inputs. Trackpad gestures, mouse buttons, keyboard shortcuts, the menu bar and a Stream Deck can all fire actions, and those actions can be chained into small automations. Logitech mouse control works without extra drivers, which suits anyone who'd rather not install another vendor's helper app. One licence covers all your personal Macs, and BTT Mobile turns an iPhone or iPad into a remote for your shortcuts. A long free trial gives plenty of time to see whether gesture-driven work sticks for you.

The downside is mainly in the licence terms. The Standard licence includes updates for a fixed period, after which the last version you received keeps working but new versions don't arrive. The Lifetime licence avoids that, at a higher one-off cost. BetterTouchTool is also sold through the Setapp subscription service, which is convenient if you already pay for Setapp, but means two routes to compare. Its automation is built from chained actions attached to inputs, so a job with heavy branching and loops may sit more naturally in Keyboard Maestro's macro editor.

Matching each app to the work on your Mac

If you spend the day in a handful of apps and repeat the same multi-step jobs, you'll probably describe the problem as a sequence: open this, copy that, check whether it worked, then file it. That's the shape Keyboard Maestro's editor is built for. Hundreds of actions, conditions and loops let the macro make the decisions you'd otherwise make by hand, and per-app Macro Groups keep each set of shortcuts in its place. Palettes help when you have more macros than you can remember keys for.

If you work mostly with a trackpad, a multi-button mouse or a Stream Deck, you'll probably describe the problem as an input: this gesture should do that, this button should open that window. That's the shape BetterTouchTool is built for. With hundreds of triggers and inputs and hundreds of actions, it can give almost any physical movement a job, and its menu bar customisation tidies the top of the screen while it's at it. The BTT Mobile companion app adds an iPhone or iPad as another input surface.

Work with me

Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?

I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.

Your own work may sit somewhere between those two descriptions, which is why the trial matters more than any feature list. Notice which way you describe your own repeated jobs, and start with the app built around that shape.

Both pay once, with different update terms

Both are one-off Mac purchases, not subscriptions, but the update terms differ. Keyboard Maestro's licence covers the current major version, which you can use indefinitely, with a paid upgrade when you want a later major version; buyers from March twenty twenty-three onwards get the current version free. BetterTouchTool's Standard licence includes two years of updates, and its Lifetime licence includes updates for as long as BetterTouchTool exists.

So the question to ask isn't only what it costs today. Ask how often you'll want new features and new macOS support, and which licence model matches that habit. Prices sit on each vendor's own pricing page, and BetterTouchTool notes its price depends on country and taxes, while Keyboard Maestro adds applicable tax. Check both before you buy, and check Setapp too if you're already a member.

Do you make Mac automation and input customisation apps? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.

Moving your shortcuts between them

Neither site documents importing the other's macros or triggers, so moving means rebuilding. Going to Keyboard Maestro, its Macro Groups can be limited to specific applications, which is the structure to rebuild BetterTouchTool's app-specific triggers into: make one group per app, then recreate each trigger as a macro inside it. Going to BetterTouchTool, one licence covers all your personal Macs, so you won't need a separate purchase for a second machine. If you're staying with Keyboard Maestro across two Macs, its sync keeps macros matched, with groups switched off per Mac where they don't belong. Rebuild your most-used shortcuts first and leave the rest until you notice you miss them.

Before you rebuild anything, sort your shortcuts into two piles: inputs you want to remap and multi-step jobs you want to automate. That split shows how much of your setup leans each way. For more options, the guide to Mac automation apps covers the wider field, and the list of Mac keyboard remapping apps covers lighter tools for changing what keys do.

Filing an email attachment, built in each app

Take a job you repeat all day, such as saving an attachment to a client folder and renaming it. In Keyboard Maestro, build it as a macro in a group limited to your mail app, add a condition that checks the file type, and fire it with a hot key. In BetterTouchTool, build the same job as a chain of actions and fire it with a three-finger trackpad gesture or a spare mouse button. Building each takes well under an hour. The telling part comes later: by the end of the week, which trigger did your hand go to without thinking, and which editor would you rather open when the folder names change? Both apps offer a free trial, so repeat the test on a second job before you decide which approach fits your hands and your habits.

Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.

Published and maintained by the Lilach Bullock team, covering marketing, AI and business growth.
Your buyers are asking AI who to use. Does it say you?

See for free whether ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google name you, and get the plan to become the answer.

Check my AI visibility →
Sundays only

Get the Sunday newsletter.

One email a week. AI experiments, marketing tactics, and the workflows Lilach is building right now in her own business.

Subscribe free

Let’s get your marketing running on AI.

Book a free 30-minute call

We figure out what you need, where AI fits in, and what working together would look like.

Book the call →

Or take the 30-second calculator

You’ll see the hours and the money quietly leaking out of your week, and the three workflows worth building first.

Take the calculator →

Or grab the free AI resource library

Prompt packs, templates, checklists, and swipe files. The exact tools I build for paying clients. Yours, free.

Get the library →
Keep reading

More from the blog.