Asset 20 8 2
Does AI recommend your business? Run the free check →

Join 15,000 business owners, marketers and entrepreneurs. The Sunday newsletter you'll be annoyed only arrives once a week.

Article

How Much AI-Written Content Is Acceptable For Your Website

If you are skim reading
Google sets no limit on how much of a website AI can write; the risk it names is publishing many AI pages that add nothing for readers.

Google sets no limit on how much of a website AI can write; the risk it names is publishing many AI pages that add nothing for readers. So there's no magic percentage, but from tracking my own site and client sites for the best part of a year, pages that keep at least 30 percent pure human input, meaning rewritten openings, real examples, and facts you checked yourself, hold up in rankings and reader trust. Treat that 30 percent as a working rule of thumb from those sites, not a threshold Google measures or uses. Pages built almost entirely from an unedited AI draft tend to plateau or quietly slide within a few months. The ratio matters less than what that human third contains.

Why I started counting the percentage in the first place

I run this blog and I write client strategy documents, so I was using AI drafts for both long before most people admitted to it. Early last year I got lazy on a client's blog. Six posts went up that were roughly 90 percent AI-generated, tidied for typos, nothing more. Traffic on those posts dropped 22 percent over six weeks compared to the posts before them. Not a Google penalty, nothing dramatic, just a slow bleed. Average time on page fell from around two minutes forty to under a minute. People were landing, skimming, and leaving.

Before you blame the writing for a slide like that, rule out technical problems with How Do You Test Your Website SEO? A Step-By-Step Process That Works in.

I rewrote all six. Same topics, same keywords, but I added named examples, specific numbers, and opening paragraphs that sounded like me rather than a generic consultant. Ten weeks later those six posts were outperforming the originals by 15 percent. Nothing else changed. That gap is where the real answer to this question lives.

The number Google cares about (it's not a percentage)

Google's own guidance on using generative AI content is clearer than most people expect. It says generative AI can be useful for researching a topic and adding structure to original content, but that using it to generate many pages without adding value for users may violate its spam policy on scaled content abuse. The problem is volume without value, whatever wrote it. That distinction matters because it means the "how much AI is allowed" question is the wrong shape entirely. You can have a site that's 80 percent AI-drafted and rank well, and a site that's 100 percent human-typed and rank badly, because it's thin, generic, and says nothing a reader couldn't get from ten other sites saying the exact same thing.

I keep a local page for Dallas with the workflows that go first there: AI consultant in Dallas.

The risk was never really the AI. The risk is that AI made it easy to produce content that sounds like everyone else's content, and Google, and readers, notice sameness fast. I wrote about this in why small business websites all sound the same now, and the honest bit in that piece still holds: most of that sameness predates ChatGPT. AI just made the copying quicker.

I've shared the ChatGPT prompts that make writing sound human I rely on.

The uncomfortable bit nobody wants to say out loud

Here's the thing that annoys me about most posts on this topic. They tell you AI content is fine "as long as you edit it," then never say what editing means, or admit that most people's edit pass is a spell check and a swap of one adjective. A carefully edited AI draft and a lightly skimmed AI draft look identical to a reader for about four seconds, and then they don't. The lightly skimmed one has no specific numbers, no named client, no year that's current, no sentence that could only have come from someone who'd done the thing. It reads fine. It just doesn't stick.

Flip it round and the same logic holds: plenty of "100% human-written" content on small business blogs is worse than a well-edited AI draft, because it was written fast by someone who doesn't enjoy writing and it shows. Purity of authorship isn't the goal. Usefulness is. I'd rather publish a post that started as an AI outline and ended up 40 percent rewritten with real detail than a post typed entirely by a tired founder at 11pm that says nothing specific at all.

My actual rule, step by step

This is the process I now use on every piece that goes on this site, and the one I hand to clients when they ask me the same question you're asking now:

  • Let AI do the first structural draft. Research, outline, a rough pass. This can be close to 100 percent AI and it's fine, nobody reads your outline.
  • Rewrite the opening two paragraphs entirely yourself. This is where a reader decides whether to trust you, and it's the part AI is worst at because it doesn't know your actual week.
  • Add one real example per major section: a client, a number, a date, a mistake you made. My rule is one specific detail for every 300 words minimum.
  • Cut every sentence that starts with "in today's fast-paced world," "it's important to note," or "when it comes to." These are AI's verbal tics and readers now spot them instantly.
  • Read the whole thing aloud. If it sounds like a brochure rather than a person, rewrite the paragraph, don't just swap synonyms.
  • Check the ending. AI-generated conclusions restate the intro. Replace it with an actual next step or opinion.
  • Fact-check everything the AI wrote, including the bits readers don't see. Google warns that generative AI output may contain inaccuracies, which it calls hallucinations, and says the review should cover title elements, meta descriptions, structured data and alt text too. Check every figure, name and quote against the original source before it goes live.

Follow those seven steps and you can start from an 80 or 90 percent AI draft and end with something that reads as fully yours, because by the time you're done, most of the sentences a reader remembers were rewritten by you.

What the AI detector tools won't tell you

I get asked constantly whether tools like GPTZero or Originality.ai should be the test. They shouldn't. I've run my own hand-typed paragraphs through them and had perfectly human writing flagged as 90 percent AI-generated, simply because it was clean and well-structured. These tools guess at pattern, not truth. Google's guidance doesn't mention detection scores at all; it tells site owners to focus on accuracy, quality and relevance. Chasing a low AI-detection score is a waste of an afternoon. Chasing specific, checkable, useful content is not.

I learned this the hard way running an automation experiment I wrote up honestly in Week 17 Flop, where I let AI handle an entire outbound sequence hands-free. It read fine sentence by sentence and completely failed at the job, because nothing in it sounded like it came from a person who'd sent a cold email and got a reply. The same failure shows up in website copy. Fluent is not the same as useful.

Where this shows up across a whole website, not just the blog

The percentage question gets harder once you look past blog posts. Your homepage, your services pages, your about page, all get the same AI-draft-then-edit treatment from most businesses now, and it's why so many small business sites read like the same template with the logo changed. A cold email has the exact same problem, which is why I wrote a separate piece on how to write a cold email that gets a reply: the AI-drafted version is always polite, always correctly formatted, and always ignored, because it has nothing specific to the person receiving it.

Your about page is the worst offender. I see AI-generated "founder stories" constantly, and they all share the same three beats: passion discovered early, gap noticed in the market, mission to help people like you. None of it is false, all of it is forgettable. That page should be closer to 90 percent your own words, because it's the one page where sameness costs you the most trust.

A quick way to audit your own site this week

Pull up your last ten published pages. To rewrite the weak ones, I walk through how to write content for SEO in my guide. For each one, ask three questions: is there a number that couldn't have come from a generic prompt, is there a name of a real person or client, and could a reader tell this was written by someone at your specific business rather than any business in your sector. If a page fails all three, that's your 90-plus percent AI page with no edit pass, and it's the one worth rewriting first, whatever traffic it currently gets, because it's the page most likely to start slipping once a reader compares it to a competitor's page that passed all three tests.

Score each page with one point per yes, then work down this list:

ScoreWhat it usually meansWhat to do
3 of 3The page has a number, a name and a voice only you could give itLeave it, and fact-check any figures older than a year
2 of 3Close, but one ingredient is missingAdd the missing piece: a checked number, a named example or your own opinion
1 of 3Mostly generic with one real detailRewrite the opening and add one real example per section
0 of 3An AI draft that never got an edit passRewrite this first, whatever traffic it gets today

Here's what one round of that looks like on a single paragraph. This is an illustration I've written for the purpose, not a client's page. A plumber's AI draft says: "When it comes to boiler servicing, it's important to choose a trusted local professional who can keep your home safe and warm all year round." Run the three questions over it. A number that couldn't come from a generic prompt? No. A real name? No. A voice a reader would know? No. That's 0 of 3.

Work with me

Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?

I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.

Now the rewrite: "We serviced 140 boilers last winter, and the fault Dave found most often was a blocked condensate pipe, which freezes in a cold snap and shuts the boiler off. It's a ten-minute fix if you catch it in October." The number and the name have to be real for your business, of course, but notice what changed: a figure, a person and an opinion about timing. That paragraph now scores 3 of 3, and no detector score was needed to get there.

I do a version of this audit every few months and report what's changing in the AI landscape in my weekly AI news roundups, partly because the tools change so fast that last year's "safe" workflow needs checking again this year.

The same sameness shows up in email too, as this blind test shows: Can you tell if an email was written by AI?

So what's the actual number

If you want one figure to hold onto: aim for at least 30 percent of your final published word count to be sentences that only you could have written, meaning specific facts, named examples, opinions with a reason behind them. It's about reader trust, and in my own testing it's the point where content stops reading as filler and starts reading as evidence you know what you're talking about. Below that, on any topic with real competition, you're gambling that nobody notices the sameness. Increasingly, they do.

You can check your own figure in about ten minutes. Paste the finished post into a document, highlight every sentence you wrote from scratch or rewrote so heavily that the AI's version is gone, then select just the highlighted text and read its word count off your word processor. Divide that by the post's total word count. A 1,200-word post with 400 highlighted words comes out at 33 percent and passes; one with 200 highlighted words is at about 17 percent, and the fix is the same as in the audit above: rewrite the opening and add one real example per section until you're back over the line.

The hard part is deciding what counts as yours. A sentence counts only if it changes what the page says: a fact you checked, an example with a name or a number, a step the AI missed, or an opinion with a reason. Swapping synonyms, reordering a list or fixing the grammar of an AI sentence doesn't count, however long it took. A quick test: could you have written that sentence without the AI draft in front of you? If not, leave it unhighlighted.

Here's a whole section worked through. Say the AI gives you a 300-word section on choosing an email tool, and none of it is highlighted, so it scores 0 percent. You replace the AI's 40-word opening with a 45-word one that says which tool you'd pick for a five-person team and why (highlighted). You add one example from your own business with the real monthly list size and what broke when you outgrew the free plan (80 words, highlighted). You delete 60 words of generic benefits that every competitor's page also lists, and you tidy the remaining AI sentences without changing what they claim (not highlighted). The section now runs to 325 words (300, minus 40, plus 45, plus 80, minus 60), with 125 of them highlighted, which is about 38 percent. My view: the cut matters as much as the additions, because deleting filler raises the share of the page that's yours without adding a word of padding.

Would you like a second pair of eyes on your business? See how I can help.

To run the ten-page check above across your whole site, follow How to Run a Website Content Audit.

If getting AI implemented in your business feels like a big job, I've broken down how it works here.

Frequently asked questions

What does Google's spam policy say about AI content?

Google says using generative AI to produce many pages without adding value for users may violate its scaled content abuse spam policy. Using AI on its own isn't the problem; mass-producing pages that help nobody is.

What percentage of my website should be human written?

There's no official figure, but based on tracking my own pages, keeping at least 30 percent of the final draft as human, meaning rewritten intros, real examples, and specific numbers, is where content stops plateauing and starts holding or growing its rankings.

Do I need to tell visitors my content used AI?

Google suggests adding information on how your content was created where it makes sense for your audience, such as background on how automation was used. It doesn't set a blanket rule. If you work in a regulated sector such as health, finance or law, check your regulator's own rules as well.

Can AI content contain mistakes?

Yes. Google warns that generative AI output may contain inaccuracies, known as hallucinations, because the models predict likely words rather than retrieve facts. Check every fact before publishing.

What about AI-generated images?

Google's guidance points ecommerce sites to Merchant Center policies, which say AI-generated images must carry IPTC DigitalSourceType TrainedAlgorithmicMedia metadata. That's a Merchant Center rule for product data, not a ranking rule, but it's good practice to add the metadata anyway.

Published and maintained by the Lilach Bullock team, covering marketing, AI and business growth.
Your buyers are asking AI who to use. Does it say you?

See for free whether ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google name you, and get the plan to become the answer.

Check my AI visibility →
Sundays only

Get the Sunday newsletter.

One email a week. AI experiments, marketing tactics, and the workflows Lilach is building right now in her own business.

Subscribe free

Let’s get your marketing running on AI.

Book a free 30-minute call

We figure out what you need, where AI fits in, and what working together would look like.

Book the call →

Or take the 30-second calculator

You’ll see the hours and the money quietly leaking out of your week, and the three workflows worth building first.

Take the calculator →

Or grab the free AI resource library

Prompt packs, templates, checklists, and swipe files. The exact tools I build for paying clients. Yours, free.

Get the library →
Keep reading

More from the blog.