If you're leaving Gelato, the right swap depends on what you sell most: a wide-catalogue partner if one design goes on lots of product types, an apparel specialist if you're a clothing brand, or a print API built for wall art if you sell prints. Then choose by where most of your buyers live, and order samples from two partners before you move a single listing.
Gelato's own help centre is organised around personalised products, store integrations and order issues, and those are exactly the three things you rebuild when you leave. Below: the partners, how to pick between them, an hour of desk work that saves you from a bad switch, and the mistakes that make moving painful.
What you're really replacing when you leave Gelato
Sellers rarely walk away from a print partner over one dramatic failure. It's usually a slow creep: a product that's dropped from the range, a colour that drifts between batches, deliveries to one country that keep slipping, or a margin squeezed one base-cost rise at a time. Whatever the trigger, the first thing to ask of any replacement is whether it can get a parcel to your main market in a sensible time, because that's the part your buyers notice.
Before you look at a single logo, pull three things from your own order history: the five products that make most of your sales, the print method behind each one (DTG on tees, embroidery on caps, fine art paper or canvas for prints), and the country where most of your buyers live. That short list does more of the choosing than any comparison page, this one included.
Four forks that decide it
Range or depth. Wide catalogues suit a shop that puts one design on mugs, tees, posters and phone cases, because you get one dashboard and one bill. Apparel specialists go deeper on fewer things: better blanks, embroidery, neck labels, branded packing. Art, prints and scale is the third pull, where a print API built for wall art or a large fulfilment network matters more than the number of products on offer.
Where it's made. Production location sets delivery time and decides whether a parcel crosses a border, with the delays and import charges that can bring. A UK printer for mostly UK buyers, or a North American network for mostly US buyers, removes a whole class of complaints before they start.
How it plugs in. Check the partner connects to the shop you run, whether that's Shopify, Etsy, WooCommerce or something else, and what happens when a customer changes an address after ordering. An API only matters if you're automating your own order flow.
Size of shop. A side-hustle Etsy store needs no upfront cost and quick setup. A brand shipping hundreds of orders a day needs capacity, consistent batches and a named person who answers when something goes wrong.
Nine print partners worth a sample order
They fall into three loose camps: wide catalogues, apparel houses and art or volume specialists. A marketplace-style platform works differently from a printer that owns its own production: the base cost and the workshop that makes your order depend on which of its print providers you choose for each product. With that kind, sample the provider, not just the platform.
Printful
One of the big wide-catalogue names: you add designs to hundreds of products, and it prints and ships each order to customers around the world.
Inkthreadable
A UK clothing specialist for brands that want white-label parcels, printed in Britain and sent worldwide.
Prodigi
Leans towards art: a platform and print API turning digital images into wall art, stationery, homewares and clothing, pitching local printing with global dropshipping.
Gooten
A fulfilment partner for sellers who want range across apparel, drinkware, wall art and accessories, with production and shipping handled for you.
PODpartner
Worth a look when embroidery or personalised pieces matter to your clothing line, with DTG printing and dropshipping alongside.
Printify
A print-on-demand platform with its own design tool, where you pick a product, drop in your artwork and decide the margin yourself.
Scalable Press
Apparel first, bringing blanks, printing and white-label fulfilment onto a single invoice, with an API for shops that automate orders.
Spreadconnect
Apparel fulfilment from the Spreadshop family that hooks into major ecommerce platforms, and the place the old SPOD address now lands.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Dreamship
Aimed at established ecommerce businesses chasing speed and scale, through a network of production facilities spread across North America.
SPOD didn't vanish, it moved
If SPOD is on your shortlist, look again. The address now redirects to Spreadconnect on Spreadshop's site, so the old name is no longer a standalone brand, even though plenty of sellers still search for it and older write-ups still use it. Read the current service's own pages fresh and don't lean on reviews written under the old name.
It's a fair warning for the whole category. Brands merge, rename and move, so make sure the company you're about to send orders to is the one you think you're dealing with.
An hour of homework before you order a single sample
Samples cost money and take days to arrive, longer if they cross a border, so do the desk work first and only sample the two partners that survive it. Here's how the hour goes, with one best-seller as the worked example.
Say your top product is a black unisex tee with a front print that sells for £24. On each shortlisted partner, find the closest blank. If you can, match the garment brand and weight, because a different tee fits differently and your sizing reviews stop making sense. Then note the base cost and the shipping to your main buyer country, and take off your marketplace or payment fees. The figures here are made up to show the sum: if partner A lands at £14.50 and partner B at £16, B costs you £1.50 on every sale, which at 200 tees a month is £300 you'd want a reason to give away.
Spend the next twenty minutes on the boring pages. Check the integration page for your shop platform, the misprint and reprint policy, where your country's orders would be produced, and whether packing slips and labels can carry your brand. Anything you can't find in ten minutes is a question for their support team, and how fast they answer it tells you something too.
Then order the samples: your two best-sellers from each of the two survivors, shipped to your own address as if you were a customer. Wash the tee, hang the print for a week, and look at what arrives in the box before anyone else's money depends on it.
What switching costs
Most partners in this category let you start free, and the usual model is per order: you pay the product's base cost plus shipping, and your margin is whatever you charge on top. Some of the wide-catalogue platforms also sell paid monthly plans that buy discounts on base costs, and the test is simple: upgrade only when the discounts outearn the fee. Do that sum on your real order count, not your hoped-for one.
The money you'll notice sits elsewhere. Samples come first, and you pay for them twice over if they cross a border. New mockups and product photos follow if the blank changes, then the hours spent rebuilding listings, rewriting size guides and re-checking every variant, and finally a few weeks of running two partners side by side while old orders clear. None of those is printed on a pricing page, so add them up yourself before you decide the move pays for itself. If a new partner saves you a little on each order but the switch eats a month of your time, give it a quarter of real sales before you call it a win.
Mistakes that make a move hurt
- Moving the whole shop in one weekend. Shift your top sellers first and leave the rest until those orders run smoothly.
- Swapping the blank without noticing. Your old reviews talk about a fit your new partner may not print on.
- Keeping the old mockups. If the garment or paper changed, the photos now promise something you don't sell.
- Believing a speed claim before your own parcel arrives. Delivery promises are the vendor's words until a sample lands.
- Disconnecting the old partner too early. Keep it live until the last open order has shipped.
Which kind of partner fits which shop
If you sell one design across lots of product types, start with a wide-catalogue partner and accept that none of them is the best at everything. If you're a clothing brand, go to an apparel specialist, and if embroidery or white-label packaging matter, narrow it to the ones that say so. If you sell art or photography, look at a print API built around wall art. If most of your buyers are in the UK, put a UK printer on the shortlist; if they're in North America, put a North American network on it. And if you're shipping at volume, ask about capacity before you ask about base costs.
Plenty of sellers end up splitting by product, one partner for clothing and another for wall art, and nothing stops you doing that once both connections are tested.
For a related decision, I've also covered the options for sellers leaving one of the biggest wide-catalogue printers, which is useful if you're weighing up a wide catalogue against a specialist.
Do you make print-on-demand or dropshipping services? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.

