An agency sending branded email for several clients, or a small marketing team that cares most about design and tidy permissions, will be better served by Campaign Monitor. A small business that wants a free plan to start on, a long list of integrations with shops and apps, and email sitting inside a wider marketing suite will get more from Mailchimp.
Picture two people opening an email tool on the same Monday. One runs a small agency and has five clients who each want a newsletter that looks like their brand, sent from an account their own staff can log into. The other runs an online shop and wants abandoned basket emails, a monthly newsletter and the shop's customer list kept in sync without a developer. Both could use either tool, but each tool is shaped for one of them.
Campaign Monitor is an email marketing platform with a template builder, automation, segmentation and signup forms, and it offers optional managed marketing services if you'd rather hand the work over. It's aimed at small marketing teams, business owners and agencies managing email across every client. Mailchimp is a marketing platform for email, automations, audience tools and integrations, sold in Free, Essentials, Standard and Premium plans. My call: agencies and design-led brands start with Campaign Monitor, shops and do-it-yourself owners start with Mailchimp.
Who should look at Campaign Monitor first
Agencies are the clearest fit. Campaign Monitor lists multiple users with permission settings and two-factor authentication, so an agency can give each client's team its own access without handing over the keys to everything. Its Enterprise plan adds multi-brand account management and a dedicated account manager, which suits a group running several brands from one place.
Design is the other draw. You get a drag-and-drop builder and a library of more than a hundred customisable, responsive templates, and A/B testing, signup forms, a preference centre and drip campaigns are part of the feature list. Its platform menu also covers transactional email, SMS, a website builder and a multi-channel marketing product, so a team can grow into more than newsletters without changing vendor.
For larger organisations with legal checks, the Enterprise plan lists GDPR and SOC security commitments with custom data processing agreements, plus invoice or purchase order billing. That's the paperwork a procurement team asks for before signing. Campaign Monitor also lists optional managed marketing services, where its team does the work for you, which suits an owner with budget but no time.
Who should look at Mailchimp first
Owners who want to start free will look here first. Mailchimp keeps a basic Free plan you can downgrade to, and its Standard plan comes with a fourteen-day free trial, so you can test the paid features before committing.
Integrations are Mailchimp's biggest advantage. Its integrations menu lists more than three hundred, including Shopify, WooCommerce, Canva and Zapier, so a shop's customers and orders can flow into email without custom work. Developers get a Marketing API, a Transactional API and webhooks for anything the integrations don't cover.
The top plan buys support and testing depth. Premium includes phone and priority support, multivariate testing as well as A/B testing, and expert help migrating your data, and it raises the monthly sending allowance to a hundred and fifty thousand emails.
Which one fits a solo owner, a developer or a designer
If you're a solo marketer or a small business owner sending one newsletter, either will do the job. Mailchimp fits if you want to start free and connect other apps, and Campaign Monitor if you care more about polished design and might bring in an agency later. It's worth comparing both with the wider field first: my guides to Mailchimp alternatives and Campaign Monitor alternatives list the other platforms in each tool's space.
If your email is about to go beyond newsletters, look at what each platform does with messages people trigger themselves, such as receipts and password resets. Mailchimp offers a Transactional API next to its Marketing API, so a developer can send both kinds from one vendor. Campaign Monitor lists transactional email and SMS in its platform menu, which keeps order messages and campaigns under the same brand controls. For a shop with a developer on hand I'd lean towards Mailchimp here; for a brand that cares more about every message matching its templates, Campaign Monitor.
If a designer hand-codes your emails, Campaign Monitor is the easier home, because it imports custom coded HTML by upload or from the web. If nobody on the team writes HTML, both builders will carry you, and the choice goes back to integrations and the free route.
Limits on each side
Campaign Monitor's route in is the free trial offered in its header, so your testing happens inside a trial window. Its pricing is set by contacts and send volume across Essentials, Premier and a custom Enterprise plan, which is fair but means the cost climbs as your list grows.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Mailchimp's limits are the send caps and where help sits. Standard sends up to six thousand emails a month, so a business mailing a growing list weekly can reach that ceiling sooner than it expects, and expert migration help is reserved for Premium.
There's a shared limit worth naming too. Both platforms price by contacts, so a list full of people who stopped opening years ago costs money on either one. Cleaning out long-inactive contacts before you compare plans can drop you into a lower tier on both, and it gives a truer picture of what each tool will cost once you're settled.
Do you make email marketing platforms? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Switching between the two
Moving into Mailchimp has its own front door: the menu carries a 'Switch to Mailchimp' link, and expert help to migrate your data comes with the Premium plan. On lower plans you'll do the move yourself. That's manageable for a small list: export your contacts with their consent status and any tags, import them, then rebuild your signup forms and automations, because those don't move on their own. Check that every form on your website points at the new account before you switch the old one off.
Moving into Campaign Monitor is easier on the design side. You can import custom coded HTML emails by upload or from the web, and import creative elements from a URL into branded templates, so a client's existing look can come across quickly. For agencies moving several clients, set up users and permission settings with two-factor authentication before you invite anyone, so each client only sees their own account.
Whichever direction you move, run both accounts side by side for a send or two. Keep the old platform live until the new one has delivered a full newsletter cleanly and your signup forms are adding contacts in the right place, then close the old account once nothing new is arriving there.
A test send from both
Before you pay for either, take your most recent newsletter and your current contact list. In Mailchimp, start on the Free plan or the Standard trial, import the list, rebuild the newsletter in the builder, and connect the one app you rely on most, such as your shop. In Campaign Monitor, start the free trial, import the same list, and bring the newsletter across by importing its HTML or pulling your brand elements from your website into a template.
Send a test of each to yourself and a colleague, then open both on a phone and a laptop. Note how long each rebuild took, which one looked closer to your brand, and how clearly each showed what your list size will cost on its pricing page. That hour will tell you more than any feature list.
Contact tiers, send caps and migration help
Both tools bill by contact count, so on the surface they look easy to compare. The difference is how they gate help. Mailchimp says expert-assisted data migration is exclusive to its Premium plan, and its Standard plan caps sending at six thousand emails a month, so a business moving a sizeable list may find the plan with migration help is also the one it needs for volume. Campaign Monitor prices by contacts and monthly send volume, from its smallest tier to lists above fifty thousand contacts, and shows the figure through a contact slider on its pricing page, so read it off the live slider for your own list size.
The fair comparison is a year, not a month. Count your contacts today and the number you expect in a year, work out how many emails you'll send each month, and check both pricing pages for that size, including any annual promotion Campaign Monitor is running on Essentials. Then add whether you'll need migration help, because on Mailchimp that changes which plan you're pricing.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.


