A hosted CAPTCHA API is the quickest way to put a bot check on a sign-up, login or contact form, and an open-source CAPTCHA you run on your own server is the pick when you'd rather keep the check in house. If where your visitors' data is processed matters to you, put the EU-made services at the top of your shortlist.
Do you want visitors to prove they're human, or do you want the check to happen without them noticing? That question splits CAPTCHA APIs before price or brand does. The second split is where the check runs: on a vendor's servers, on your own, or on servers in the EU.
Everything below is about one job: stopping bots on the forms you own, such as sign-up, login and contact. It's not a guide to whole-site bot management, which is a bigger buy; my list of bot protection tools covers that.
Questions to settle before you add a CAPTCHA to a form
Do I want a puzzle on the form, or a check visitors never see?
That's the first fork, and the vendors split on it. Cloudflare Turnstile's widget has a mode that's completely hidden from the visitor, and Friendly Captcha describes its approach as proof-of-work rather than image puzzles. A hidden check is kinder to real people, but you can't eyeball whether it's working, so you'll lean on the dashboard and your own logs instead. For a contact form that gets a trickle of spam, I'd start invisible. For a login page that's being hammered, keep a visible fallback in reserve.
Should the check run on the vendor's servers or on mine?
A hosted service means someone else runs the challenge and keeps it up, and you look after two small pieces: the widget on your form and the check on your server. The open-source options on this list are code you deploy, update and watch yourself, which suits a team that already runs its own servers and would rather not send form traffic to a third party. Whichever way you go, open the docs and find the server-side verification step before anything else. A CAPTCHA that only runs in the browser isn't protecting anything.
Does an EU-made CAPTCHA help with GDPR?
It can make the conversation shorter, but it doesn't do the work for you. Private Captcha sells itself as GDPR-compliant and made in the EU, for forms and APIs. What you still need to know, from any vendor, is what the check collects, where it's processed and how long it's kept, because that's what goes in your privacy notice. Ask for those answers in writing and file them with your other processor records.
How do CAPTCHA APIs charge?
By volume, in the plans that show a number. CaptchaFox sets its plans by monthly requests, and MTCaptcha measures its free plan in evaluations a month. That makes your real traffic the bill driver, and bots are part of that traffic, so ask each vendor whether a blocked attempt counts towards the total. Prices sit on each vendor's pricing page; read the line about what happens when you go over the included amount, not only the headline figure.
Will a free plan or a trial cover a small site?
Check each one, because the wording varies. MTCaptcha has a free plan for personal sites and testing, and mCaptcha's site says it will always be free. A trial is a different promise: it ends, so put the end date in your calendar the day you sign up, and check the plan you'd move to before your form depends on it.
When does a form need more than a CAPTCHA?
When the problem is fraud rather than junk messages. A spam-filled contact form is a CAPTCHA job; fake accounts or bots working through your checkout are a fraud job. Arkose Labs, for one, pitches a platform for deciding which AI agents to trust and stopping fraud. If bots are hitting the whole site rather than one form, you're shopping for a wider product than this list covers.
How can I test a CAPTCHA API in an hour before I commit?
Put it on a copy of your real form on a staging site, then submit it ten times yourself from a phone and a laptop, timing each one. Next, post the form from a script without the token and with an old token, and confirm your server rejects both. Then fill it in on the slowest phone you own, and check that the dashboard shows every attempt you made. Anything that fails a step there will fail on the live site too.
How do I keep it cheap to switch later?
Wrap the server-side check in one function in your own code, so the rest of the app only ever asks one question: did this submission pass? Swapping vendors then means changing the widget and that one function, not hunting through every form handler. If your forms post to a hosted form service rather than your own server, check which CAPTCHA providers that service accepts before you pick one.
Ten CAPTCHA APIs for sign-up, login and contact forms
hCaptcha
A hosted CAPTCHA and bot-detection platform; its enterprise side describes passive and No-CAPTCHA modes plus server-side API protection.
Cloudflare Turnstile
Cloudflare's hosted CAPTCHA alternative is a widget with an invisible mode that stays completely hidden from the person filling in your form.
Friendly Captcha
Built on proof-of-work instead of image puzzles, this invisible CAPTCHA runs as a hosted service and publishes open-source libraries for popular frameworks.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
ALTCHA
Self-hostable CAPTCHA and bot-protection software, also offered as a cloud service when you'd rather not run it yourself.
Arkose Labs
An enterprise bot and fraud platform that pitches itself on deciding which AI agents to trust and stopping fraud that costs money.
mCaptcha
Open-source proof-of-work CAPTCHA whose own site calls it so silent that the people using your form won't even feel it.
CaptchaFox
A CAPTCHA and bot-protection service that says it's built and hosted in Europe, and describes itself as GDPR-compliant.
MTCaptcha
A hosted CAPTCHA service whose home page leads with enterprise CAPTCHA and bot protection rather than a simple form widget pitch.
Cap
Open-source and self-hosted, Cap calls itself an alternative to reCAPTCHA, and everything it lists ships in the open-source release.
Private Captcha
Made in the EU for forms and APIs, this GDPR-compliant CAPTCHA service is hosted, with an option to self-host it instead.
Where I'd start, by kind of form
For a small business contact form, I'd start with a hosted invisible check on a free plan or trial and give it a fortnight of real traffic before deciding anything. For a product sign-up or login page, I'd shortlist one hosted service and one open-source option, run the hour-long test on both and keep whichever your developer is happier maintaining. If the form posts to a hosted service instead, compare form backend services on which CAPTCHA providers they accept.
For a business that has to answer awkward questions about visitor data, I'd put the EU-made services first and get the data answers in writing before a line of code goes in. And if the losses are coming from fraud rather than spam, don't stretch a form CAPTCHA to cover it: price an enterprise bot and fraud platform alongside it.
Do you make CAPTCHA or bot-check APIs? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.

