Campaign Monitor is an email marketing platform built around brand control and expert help, with locked template sections for shared accounts and a deliverability team on hand; Constant Contact is a wider digital marketing suite that adds SMS, events, social and ecommerce tools, plus a Teams product for organisations running many accounts. Campaign Monitor fits a sender who wants email done carefully with specialist support; Constant Contact fits a business that wants several marketing channels under one login.
Picture a marketing manager looking after a chain of shops. Head office wants every email on-brand, each branch wants to send its own news, and someone keeps asking about text messages and event invitations. That's the exact situation where Campaign Monitor and Constant Contact both come up, and where they start to pull in different directions. Run through the list below before you book a demo with either.
Eight things to confirm before choosing between these email platforms
- Whether your emails go out from one central team or from several branches, locations or departments that each need their own account.
- Whether brand control means locking parts of a template so local teams can only edit the sections you allow.
- Whether you need channels beyond email, such as SMS, event marketing, social posting or ecommerce, inside the same tool.
- How many contacts you hold today and how often you send, because both shape the bill on these platforms.
- Whether you'd like a specialist team to help with deliverability and campaign planning, or you'd rather do it all in-house.
- What checks run before you press send, so broken links or design problems get caught early.
- How much you want AI to take on, from suggestions on a single email to running whole campaigns.
- Which free trial you'll use, and the real campaign you'll build during it to test both side by side.
How each platform answers that list
Accounts and brand control. Campaign Monitor offers shared accounts with flexible permissions and locked template sections, so every team stays on-brand while still editing its own content. Constant Contact handles the same need through multiple accounts, pitched as a way to stay on-brand and manage your marketing across teams, locations and accounts, and through its Teams product for distributed organisations. Constant Contact says Teams helps those organisations scale marketing without adding headcount, and its page flags the product for anyone managing several accounts.
Channels. This is the clearest split. Constant Contact lists email marketing, SMS marketing, event marketing, automation, reporting and analytics, email templates, social media marketing, ecommerce, list-building tools and AI in one suite. Campaign Monitor keeps its focus on email, and for channels outside the inbox it offers CM360, which gives you a dedicated team working on the channels that fit your goals.
Expert help. Campaign Monitor leans on people. Its full-service email support is pitched on the line that you don't have to be an email expert to get expert results, its deliverability experts help diagnose and fix what's holding your emails back, and its Expert Services page sets out what the team can take on. Round-the-clock access to its resources and help documentation sits alongside that.
Checks and AI. Campaign Monitor runs built-in checks to catch issues before you send, and its new Campaign Series feature reviews an email for content and design and gives personalised suggestions. Constant Contact's Premium plan is aimed at pros who want automation and segmentation, and its Catalyst beta is described as an AI team that does all your marketing from start to finish. That's Constant Contact's own description, so put it to work on a real campaign before you rely on it.
Contacts, sends and trials. Your list size matters on both, and on Constant Contact your sending volume does too, so the items on the checklist about contacts and frequency aren't admin: they decide which plan you land on. Both platforms offer a free trial, which makes the last item on the list the one to take seriously. A trial spent clicking around the dashboard tells you very little. A trial spent building and testing the newsletter you'll send next month tells you how each platform feels on a busy Tuesday, when the email has to go out and the branch manager wants one more change.
What drives the bill on each
Neither platform's figures belong here, because plans and allowances change. What matters is how each one works out your cost. Campaign Monitor sells tiered plans set by your number of contacts. Constant Contact bases its plan price on your number of contacts and your email sends, across plans that include Standard and Premium.
In practice that means two numbers to have ready: the size of your list today and how often you mail it. A business that sends a lot to a modest list and one that sends rarely to a large list can land in very different places on the same platform. Both offer a free trial, and each vendor's pricing page has the current plans. If price is the deciding question for you, my breakdown of how Constant Contact's plans are put together goes further.
Moving your list and templates across
The thing to protect in any move is brand consistency. If you're going to Campaign Monitor, plan your shared accounts and decide which template sections you'll lock before you invite local teams, because those permissions are what keep everyone on-brand. If you're going to Constant Contact, set up its multiple accounts so each team, location or account has its own space, and decide early whether its Teams product suits how your organisation is spread out.
Either way, export your contacts with their sign-up source and preferences, rebuild your most-used template first, and send a test campaign to an internal list before anything reaches a customer. Check each vendor's help docs for how imports handle unsubscribes, so nobody who opted out ends up back on the list.
Give yourself a cut-over date and keep the old account open until a couple of campaigns have gone out cleanly from the new one. Reports from the old platform are worth downloading before you close it, because they're your baseline for judging whether the move has helped.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Where each one asks more of you
Campaign Monitor's focus on email means you'll need other tools, or its CM360 team, for channels such as SMS or events. Its expert help is a large part of its appeal, so find out what the services side covers on the plan you're looking at, and make sure someone on your team will use it.
Constant Contact's breadth means more to learn and more to set up. A suite that covers email, SMS, events, social and ecommerce rewards a team that will use several of those channels, and pricing that follows both contacts and sends means a busy sending schedule needs watching.
Locked templates against a multi-channel suite
Here's the difference in one breath. Campaign Monitor leans on a services team and locked template sections, which suits an organisation that wants email done carefully, on-brand, with specialists on call. Constant Contact prices by contacts and email sends and sells a Teams product for multi-location organisations, which suits a business that wants many channels and many accounts under one roof. Neither approach is a compromise. They're built for different shapes of marketing team. If you'd like to see more options before choosing, my guide to other email platforms people weigh against Campaign Monitor lines up the wider field.
Do you make email marketing platforms? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
An hour inside both free trials
Start a free trial on each and build the same real email, such as next month's newsletter.
In Campaign Monitor, set up a shared account with a colleague, lock the header and footer of your template, and let them edit only the middle. Run the built-in checks before sending a test, and try Campaign Series on the draft to see what it suggests.
In Constant Contact, build the same newsletter from its email templates, then look at how you'd add an SMS reminder or an event invitation to the same campaign. If you run more than one location, open the multiple accounts setup and see how each branch would get its own space.
By the end of the hour you'll know whether your team values tight template control and expert help, or a wider set of channels in one place, and that's the choice these two platforms are asking you to make.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.


