- Pick the model before the app
- Which model fits your store
- Services that decide or review orders for you
- Apps that score, screen or fight disputes
- False declines are the bill you never see
- Start with your own last few chargebacks
- Three things worth knowing before you shortlist
- How the bill is worked out
- Test it on last quarter's chargebacks
Who carries the risk is the first question for a Shopify fraud prevention app: a guaranteed service backs its decisions with cover against fraud chargebacks, while a scoring app gives you the rules and leaves the losses with you. A small store with the odd bad order can start with a scoring app on a free plan; stores where chargebacks are eating margin should price up guaranteed cover.
Stopping fraud is the easy half. Decline every order that looks odd and you'll have almost no chargebacks, and quite a lot fewer customers. The hard half is telling a stolen card from a real buyer who's using a work address, a new phone or a card from another country. That's the job you're hiring one of these apps to do, and the four models below do it in very different ways.
Pick the model before the app
| Model | How it works | Suits | Ask before you sign |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guaranteed chargeback cover | The service makes the call on each order and backs it with a guarantee against fraud chargebacks | Stores where fraud losses are steady and painful | Which chargeback reasons are covered, and what the charge is tied to |
| Decisions or order review done for you | A service decides on each order in real time or reviews it before you fulfil; the review services pitch stopping chargebacks while approving more good orders | Stores turning away too many legitimate orders | How fast decisions come back, and whether any protection comes with them |
| Scoring and screening | The app scores or screens each order for risk, and some let you write your own rules on top | Smaller stores and owners who like control | Whether you can set rules, and what they can use: country, order value, repeat details |
| Prevention plus dispute help | Screens orders before shipping and contests the chargebacks that still arrive | Stores already losing time fighting disputes | Which disputes it will fight and how it gets paid |
The table is the decision. Everything else on this page is detail inside one row.
Which model fits your store
A small store with the occasional bad order: a scoring app on a free plan, with a handful of rules you've checked against your own history. Keep the rules few and review them monthly. If you're still building your app stack, our pick of Shopify apps for small stores will help you decide what earns a slot.
A growing store where chargebacks hurt every month: get quotes from the guaranteed services and compare them with what fraud cost you last year, fees included.
A store that suspects it's declining too many good orders: look at managed review first, because approving more legitimate orders is the whole pitch.
A store drowning in disputes: a tool that pairs prevention with automated dispute handling should save you the hours you're spending on paperwork by hand.
One trap whichever row you land in: two scoring tools on the same orders can disagree with each other, and you'll be back to checking every order by hand.
Services that decide or review orders for you
Signifyd
AI decisions at checkout, backed by a financial guarantee against fraud chargebacks, covering the customer journey from checkout through to returns.
Riskified
If guaranteed chargeback protection is what you're after, this is the other service on this list offering it, with fraud decisions made in real time.
Forter
Real-time trust decisions on online transactions across the shopping journey, judging whether each one should go through.
Wyllo (formerly NoFraud)
A fraud protection service that reviews your orders for you, aimed at getting more of the legitimate ones approved instead of cancelled.
Evereye
Order review before fulfilment, for merchants who want chargebacks stopped while letting more real customers through.
Apps that score, screen or fight disputes
Chargeflow
Two jobs in one app: catching fraud before you ship, then automatically contesting the chargebacks that still land.
Fraud Shield
Built by a payments company, this scoring app lets you fine-tune fraud rules to your business and keep false positives down.
FraudGuard Chargeback Protect
Scores orders in real time and blocks the risky ones through custom rules you set, including blocks by country.
Sensfrx
Watches the whole customer journey with AI monitoring, and goes after bots and abuse as well as fraud and chargebacks.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
FraudLabs Pro
A fraud screening service that supports Shopify among other platforms and checks each order for high-risk signals.
False declines are the bill you never see
Chargebacks are loud: you hear about every single one. A false decline is silent. A real customer is cancelled or blocked, gets annoyed, and buys from someone else. You never see the invoice for that, and that's how filters end up tuned far too tight.
Every rule you add should earn its place twice, once by catching fraud and once by not catching your customers. If a rule like "cancel all orders where billing and shipping countries differ" would have blocked ten good orders to stop one bad one, it's costing you money even though your chargeback rate looks lovely.
That's the pitch behind managed review: approve more of the orders a stricter filter would have thrown away. Hold every option here to the same lens, whatever model it sells.
Start with your own last few chargebacks
Before you install anything, spend twenty minutes with your last few chargebacks. Open each order and look for the warning signs you'd have wanted: a rushed first order, mismatched addresses, anything your admin already flagged. It's also worth checking what your current Shopify plan includes before you pay for more. If most showed warning signs and you shipped anyway, you don't need a new app yet; you need a habit of reviewing risky orders before fulfilment.
If the chargebacks looked clean, that's the sign you've outgrown checking by eye. It's also worth reading up on the different types of ecommerce fraud, because friendly fraud, where a real customer disputes a real order, is hard for an order-scoring tool to catch: the order itself looks fine. Those disputes can come late, too: the FTC's guidance on disputing credit card charges tells US cardholders their letter must reach the card issuer within 60 days after the first bill with the error was sent.
Do you make Shopify fraud prevention apps? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Three things worth knowing before you shortlist
First, guaranteed cover sits in the Shopify App Store next to the free filters: both guaranteed services here install from a listing like any other app, so you don't need a sales call just to look.
Second, names move. NoFraud's site now carries the Wyllo name, so if someone recommends NoFraud to you, that's the one to look for.
Third, prevention and dispute recovery can come in one app. Chargeflow is the example here, pairing pre-shipment screening with automatic chargeback disputes. That's useful if you're fighting disputes by hand, but check whether you'd rather keep prevention and disputes with separate specialists. Our wider guide to fraud detection software covers tools that sit beyond Shopify, if you sell on other channels too.
How the bill is worked out
Four of the ten list a free plan on their Shopify listing. Four more are free to install with charges that may apply, and that includes both guaranteed services, so their real rate only shows once you're further in. Of the last two, one shows a paid monthly plan on its listing and the other shows no price where we looked.
Only three put an actual figure on the listing, and they span a wide range: from a free plan, through about ten dollars a month, to about five hundred dollars a month for a managed review service. The guaranteed services publish no rate at all, so the only way to compare them is a quote against your own order volume.
Rather than comparing headline prices, ask each vendor what the charge is tied to: orders screened, the value of orders approved, or a flat plan. Then put that against your own chargeback losses and an honest guess at the good orders you're turning away today.
Test it on last quarter's chargebacks
- List every fraud chargeback from the last three months, with the order number and the date you shipped.
- Add a matching list of ten or twenty orders that looked unusual but turned out fine: big first orders, different billing and shipping addresses, overseas cards.
- Before you commit, ask the vendor or check the app to see how it would have scored both lists. A scoring app you can test yourself; with a managed service, ask whether it can run the lists for you.
- Count two numbers: chargebacks it would have stopped, and good orders it would have declined. The second number decides more than the first.
- Check the operations side too. How long does an order sit waiting for a decision, and what does your team see while it waits?
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.


