- The short answer for on-call and SRE teams
- What PagerDuty does well
- What Rootly does well
- How the AI side compares
- Where your responders spend the day
- Where each one asks more of you
- Two pricing models, and an open invitation to switch
- What moving between them involves
- A one-hour dry run with a single service
For an engineering organisation that wants one broad reliability platform with a deep catalogue of ready-made integrations, PagerDuty fits; for a team that wants incident response run inside Slack, Teams or Google Chat and priced per person, Rootly fits. Both cover on-call and incidents, so the split is how you buy and where your responders already work.
PagerDuty isn't sold under quite the same name any more. It's now the PD Reliability Platform, which the company describes as AI-first, with an SRE agent called Paige built in. Rootly is an incident response and on-call platform that runs inside Slack, Teams or Google Chat, with AI agents of its own. So this comparison is between an established on-call platform that has rebuilt itself around AI and a newer tool built around the chat window from the start.
The short answer for on-call and SRE teams
PagerDuty fits a larger engineering organisation that wants one platform to take in alerts from everywhere, run on-call schedules and escalations, automate runbooks and keep stakeholders informed, and that's comfortable with an annual platform fee. Its catalogue of ready-made integrations runs into the hundreds, and it can take data by email, custom API or MCP when there's no ready-made option.
Rootly fits a team whose incidents already happen in a chat channel, that wants responders to declare, investigate and page from Slack, Teams or Google Chat, and that would rather pay per user for each product it uses. A startup programme offers a discount for companies under a hundred employees, which makes it a natural one to look at if you're a smaller company buying your first on-call tool.
Both are full incident tools. The choice between them rests on three things: how your company prefers to buy software, whether your responders live in chat, and how much of the move you want someone else to carry.
What PagerDuty does well
PagerDuty's incident product bundles on-call scheduling and escalations, runbook automation and stakeholder communications in one place, so a large team can keep the whole response loop inside one system. Its integration catalogue lists more than seven hundred and fifty ready-made connections, and when your tool isn't on the list, incoming data can arrive by email, through a custom API or over MCP. Every plan comes with a free trial, so you can wire up a real monitoring tool before signing anything. For companies that run ServiceNow, a two-way sync is available, reserved for the Ultimate tier.
What Rootly does well
Rootly's Incident Response product runs inside Slack, Teams or Google Chat, so responders don't need to leave the conversation to work an incident. In Microsoft Teams you can mention Rootly to investigate, check recent deploys and page responders. On-Call is a separate product for routing alerts and paging, and AI SRE is available on request for teams that already use Incident Response. Rootly lists ninety-five integrations across ten categories, from alerting through to HR systems, and says it has an MCP server so incidents can be handled from inside the IDE. At the top end, Enterprise adds SCIM, audit logs, bring-your-own AI key and custom data retention.
How the AI side compares
Both vendors now put AI at the front of the pitch, in different ways. PagerDuty builds it into the platform itself: the PD Reliability Platform is described as AI-first, its SRE agent is called Paige, and AI Actions appear as a usage allowance inside each tier, so AI work is metered alongside everything else. Rootly sells AI SRE as its own product, available on request and only alongside Incident Response, and it extends AI into the places engineers already work, with an MCP server for handling incidents from the IDE and, on Enterprise, the option to bring your own AI key.
That difference matters for planning. With PagerDuty, the question to ask is how many AI Actions your tier includes and what happens when you reach the allowance. With Rootly, the question is whether you want AI SRE at all, since it's an add-on you request rather than something switched on by default. If a specific AI feature would change your choice, ask each vendor to show it working on one of your own past incidents during the evaluation.
Where your responders spend the day
A quieter question often settles this faster than any feature list: where are your engineers when the pager goes off? If your team already coordinates incidents in a Slack, Teams or Google Chat channel, Rootly's design meets them there, down to mentioning it in Teams to check deploys. If your organisation runs response from a central platform, with schedules, runbooks and stakeholder updates owned by an operations function, PagerDuty's bundled incident product matches that shape. Ask the people who carry the pager, not only the person who signs the contract.
Where each one asks more of you
PagerDuty asks for a bigger commitment up front. Its tiers carry annual platform fees, extra seats are bought in credits rather than plain money, and each tier caps Signal Intelligence Events, which are the accepted events sent to its events API, email integrations included. A noisy monitoring setup can eat into that allowance, so it pays to know your alert volume before you pick a tier. The ServiceNow two-way sync sitting only on Ultimate matters if you're an IT-heavy business.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Rootly asks you to think product by product. Incident Response and On-Call are priced separately, AI SRE requires Incident Response and comes by quote, and the security features larger companies often need, such as SCIM and audit logs, sit in Enterprise. Its integration list is shorter than PagerDuty's, so check that your monitoring, ticketing and deploy tools are on it before you plan a move. A free route isn't stated on its pages, so ask about trial access when you contact the team.
Two pricing models, and an open invitation to switch
This is the part that shapes the bill most. PagerDuty now bills an annual platform fee per tier, with seats paid in credits and a capped number of Signal Intelligence Events inside each tier, and AI Actions counted as a usage allowance too. Rootly lists a per-user, per-month price for each product, with AI SRE and Enterprise by quote. One model grows with tier and event volume, the other grows with headcount and the number of products you add. Run your own numbers: a small team with heavy alert traffic and a large team with quiet systems will get very different answers from the same two price lists. The current figures sit on each vendor's pricing page.
There's a second thing worth knowing. Rootly's homepage runs a switching offer aimed directly at PagerDuty customers. Vendor claim: Rootly offers PagerDuty switchers a contract buyout and migrates PagerDuty accounts for them. That's an offer from one vendor about the other, so read its terms closely, and weigh it as one input among several rather than the reason to move.
Do you make incident management and on-call platforms? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
What moving between them involves
If you're moving from PagerDuty to Rootly, the main draw on Rootly's side is the migration help it advertises for PagerDuty accounts, along with the contract buyout it offers switchers, both as vendor claims you'll want in writing. If you're moving towards PagerDuty, its ability to accept incoming data by email, custom API or MCP is the route for pointing your existing monitors at the new tool. In either direction, rebuild schedules and escalation rules first, send test alerts from every monitor, and run both tools in parallel for a full on-call rotation before you switch the old one off. My guide to PagerDuty alternatives covers other tools if neither of these fits.
A one-hour dry run with a single service
Pick one real service with a monitor you trust. In PagerDuty's free trial, connect that monitor, set up a schedule with two responders and an escalation rule, then fire a test alert and watch who gets paged and how the incident record fills in. In Rootly, connect the same monitor, add its workspace to your Slack, Teams or Google Chat, declare a test incident from the chat window and page a responder from there.
Then compare the two experiences against your team, not against each other. Ask the responders which run felt closer to a normal bad night: one platform holding the schedule, the runbook and the stakeholder updates, which is PagerDuty's shape, or the whole incident worked from the chat channel, which is Rootly's. If the schedule itself was the sticking point, my roundup of on-call scheduling software goes deeper on that one job.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.


