Asset 20 8 2
Does AI recommend your business? Run the free check →

Join 15,000 business owners, marketers and entrepreneurs. The Sunday newsletter you'll be annoyed only arrives once a week.

Article

Mailchimp vs MailPoet for a WordPress or WooCommerce Site

Mailchimp fits a business that wants its email list and sending hosted outside the website, with a large integration directory and round-the-clock support; MailPoet fits a WordPress or WooCommerce owner who wants email built and sent from inside the dashboard, store emails included. The real fork is where your list lives, and both sides make a fair case.

Where should your email list live: on a dedicated platform somewhere else, or inside the WordPress site you already run? That one question sorts most of the Mailchimp and MailPoet decision before you look at a single feature. Mailchimp is a hosted email and SMS marketing platform with audiences, automations, templates and reporting. MailPoet is an email marketing plugin that runs inside a WordPress site and offers its own optional sending service. Both send newsletters and automated emails; they simply start from different homes.

Where your list and your sending live

With Mailchimp, your contacts, templates and reports sit on Mailchimp's servers, and you log in to a separate account to write and send. That keeps email independent of your website: if you rebuild the site or move hosts, your list doesn't move with it. Mailchimp says it offers round-the-clock support, and paid plans come with onboarding specialists to help you get going.

With MailPoet, the plugin lives in your WordPress dashboard. You write emails next to your posts, and on a WooCommerce shop the store emails are part of the same place, including an automated cart recovery email for abandoned purchases. MailPoet says more than half a million websites use it, which tells you it's a well-trodden route on WordPress. Sending can go through MailPoet's own service or through a route you manage yourself, depending on the plan.

Hosted platform or WordPress plugin: the upside and the downside

The upside of a hosted platform is separation and reach. Your email keeps running whatever happens to the website, and a large directory of connections makes it easier to plug into a store, a CRM or a form tool that isn't WordPress. The downside is a second system to log in to, and your contact data lives outside the site, so syncing customers from a shop depends on an integration staying healthy.

The upside of a plugin is closeness. Posts, products and customers are already in WordPress, so emails about them don't need a bridge, and there's one login for the lot. The downside is that your email setup now shares a home with the website: plugin updates, hosting and the sending route all become things you look after. If WordPress isn't the centre of your business, that closeness matters far less.

The hosted route fits a business with tools spread across several platforms; the plugin route fits a business that already runs on WordPress and wants fewer moving parts. My roundup of WordPress newsletter plugins covers the plugin side in more depth if you want to see the wider field.

Where Mailchimp pulls ahead

Mailchimp's integration directory lists more than three hundred connections to common stores and tools, so it fits a business whose website is only one of several places customers come from. You can start with a fourteen-day free trial, and if a paid plan stops making sense you can cancel or drop back to the basic Free plan at any time. Larger lists get a discount when you join. Sending is capped by plan: the Standard plan sets a monthly email limit, and Premium raises that cap by a wide margin, with expert migration help and strategic guidance included at that tier.

Where MailPoet pulls ahead

MailPoet fits the WordPress owner who wants email inside the site. The Starter plan is free and caps monthly sending, the Business plan removes that cap entirely, and the Agency plan lets one licence cover fifty websites, which suits someone who builds or manages client sites. The Creator plan is aimed at people who want to manage their own email sending. On the shop side, WooCommerce store emails such as cart recovery are built in, and if you're weighing other shop add-ons, my list of WooCommerce marketing extensions sits alongside this. MailPoet's pricing page also states that its sending service can send over fifty thousand emails an hour (vendor claim).

Where each one stops short

Mailchimp's limits are about volume and plan level. The Standard plan's monthly send cap is a real ceiling for anyone mailing a growing list several times a week, overages apply once you pass your contact or send limit, and the expert migration help you might want when moving in is kept for Premium. None of that is unusual for a hosted platform, but it means you'll want to watch your monthly sends rather than set and forget.

MailPoet's limits are about where it can run. It's a WordPress plugin, so it fits only if your site is on WordPress, and it ties your email to the health of that site. The free Starter plan caps monthly sending, and the Creator plan hands the sending route to you, which is freedom for some owners and an extra job for others. If your business lives across several platforms, the plugin model asks you to bring everything back to WordPress first.

Work with me

Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?

I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.

Plan limits, imports and the sending route

Here's what to know before you commit. MailPoet's own pricing table lists an import from Mailchimp as a feature, so arriving from Mailchimp is a route it expects. Its Creator plan matches Business except that it leaves out MailPoet's sending service, so on Creator you send through your own route and that route becomes your responsibility. Mailchimp, for its part, says migration help is exclusive to its Premium plan, and it warns that overages apply when you pass your contact or send limit.

Put plainly: on Mailchimp, a list that grows quickly or a busy sending month can push the bill past your plan; on MailPoet, picking Creator to keep control of sending also means keeping control of deliverability. Both rules sit on the vendors' own pages, and they shape what you pay and what you look after.

What the bill depends on

Mailchimp prices each plan tier by contact count, with a monthly email send limit per plan and overages beyond it. MailPoet prices each plan tier by list size, and Starter is free for a small list. So for both, the number of people on your list is the main driver, and with Mailchimp the number of emails you send each month matters too. Exact figures change, so check each vendor's own pricing page on the day you decide rather than relying on any comparison you read. One more lever sits on the MailPoet side: Creator drops the sending service, so your own sending route becomes part of the running cost. On Mailchimp, dropping back to the basic Free plan is always open if a paid tier stops earning its keep.

Do you make email marketing platforms and newsletter plugins? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.

Moving a list from one to the other

Going from Mailchimp to MailPoet has the more documented route. MailPoet's plan table includes importing from Mailchimp, and its knowledge base has a Migrating to MailPoet section covering how to move contacts, lists and content from other email tools. Going the other way, Mailchimp says expert migration help is part of its Premium plan, so on lower plans you'll do the move yourself. Whichever direction you go, export your list first, keep a copy, rebuild your welcome and cart emails before you switch them on, and send a test to yourself from the new tool before your next real send.

An hour-long trial run on your own site

You can test both in an afternoon without touching your real list. Start Mailchimp's fourteen-day trial and install MailPoet's free Starter plan on a staging copy of your WordPress site, or on the live site if you don't have one. In each, import a small test list of your own addresses, build one welcome email that goes out when someone joins, and write one newsletter that features your latest post.

Then compare what you did. Where did you keep reaching? Opening a separate tab and using connections to other tools points to Mailchimp's way of working; writing beside your posts and products, with the store emails close by, points to MailPoet's. Note how each one handled sending and which plan limit you'd meet first as your list grows.

Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.

Published and maintained by the Lilach Bullock team, covering marketing, AI and business growth.
Your buyers are asking AI who to use. Does it say you?

See for free whether ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google name you, and get the plan to become the answer.

Check my AI visibility →
Sundays only

Get the Sunday newsletter.

One email a week. AI experiments, marketing tactics, and the workflows Lilach is building right now in her own business.

Subscribe free

Let’s get your marketing running on AI.

Book a free 30-minute call

We figure out what you need, where AI fits in, and what working together would look like.

Book the call →

Or take the 30-second calculator

You’ll see the hours and the money quietly leaking out of your week, and the three workflows worth building first.

Take the calculator →

Or grab the free AI resource library

Prompt packs, templates, checklists, and swipe files. The exact tools I build for paying clients. Yours, free.

Get the library →
Keep reading

More from the blog.