Start with what you sell, because that's what separates these platforms most. Digital downloads suit a simple store or link-based checkout. Courses and memberships need a course platform with a community or student area. Merch and physical goods point to a branded shop or a full ecommerce platform.
Three kinds of seller end up looking for a new store, and the right platform for each is different. Which one are you?
- Downloads such as ebooks, templates, presets or music files.
- Courses and memberships, where people log in, learn and come back.
- Merch or physical products, from printed shirts to handmade goods.
Sellfy sells itself as a store builder for downloads, subscriptions and merch sold straight to your audience. The nine platforms below each lean towards one of those three baskets. They're in no particular order, and the table comes first so you can scan them quickly.
Nine creator stores in one table
| Tool | Built for | Good for |
|---|---|---|
| Big Cartel | Store builder for artists | A simple shop for makers and small businesses |
| Fourthwall | Merch and branded shops | Custom merch and memberships on a branded site |
| Hotmart | Digital product platform | Selling and distributing digital products at scale |
| Ko-fi | Creator page with shop | Tips, small product sales and memberships |
| Podia | Courses, community and email | Courses, coaching and email from one dashboard |
| SendOwl | Digital product selling | Checkout from any link you share |
| Shopify | General ecommerce platform | Growing into a full online business |
| Teachable | Courses and coaching platform | Courses, coaching and downloads under one brand |
| Thinkific | Course platform | Building courses and communities with drag and drop |
Downloads, courses or merch
Downloads and simple stores. SendOwl and Big Cartel lead with the store itself. One is built around selling from wherever you can share a link, the other around a clean shop for artists and small businesses. Ko-fi starts from a creator page instead, with a shop added to tips and memberships, and Hotmart frames itself around distributing digital products.
Courses and memberships. Podia, Teachable and Thinkific lead with courses. They're the right side of the list if your main product is teaching, coaching or a members area, with community and email tools around it.
Merch and general ecommerce. Fourthwall leads with merch and branded shops for creators, and Shopify is the general commerce platform for brands that expect to grow into a full online business with many products and channels.
How each one takes its share of a sale
This is the comparison that catches people out. Sellfy's own page says it doesn't take a cut of each sale, and that's often the reason creators chose it. The alternatives treat per-sale charges very differently on their own pages, and the wording sits in different places: on a plan page, in a help article or folded into payment processing.
That's why the headline on a homepage isn't enough. Once you've picked a basket, open each shortlisted vendor's plan page and read the current wording on transaction charges, payment processing and payouts. The wording changes, so read it on the day you decide.
Each store, A to Z
Sorted alphabetically, in no particular order. Every description reflects the vendor's own claims.
Big Cartel
Best for: Artists and small businesses who want a simple online store; the vendor says you can start a free store and scale as you grow.
Fourthwall
Best for: Creators selling custom products and memberships from a branded website, which the vendor describes as one platform for premium products and branded shops.
Hotmart
Best for: Sellers who want a platform built around selling and distributing digital products, as the vendor positions itself.
Ko-fi
Best for: Makers and writers who'd like a free page for tips, product sales and memberships, with the vendor also pitching it as a way to grow your community.
Podia
Best for: Coaches and educators selling courses, hosting a community and emailing their list in one place, per the vendor.
SendOwl
Best for: Sellers of digital products, services, memberships and content who want to sell from anywhere they can paste a link, directly to customers, says the vendor.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Shopify
Best for: Brands that want a commerce platform to build and grow a business online, which the vendor says goes beyond ecommerce software.
Teachable
Best for: Course creators and businesses selling courses, coaching and digital products, according to the vendor's own description.
Thinkific
Best for: Educators building online courses and communities with a drag-and-drop builder and LMS tools, which the vendor calls an all-in-one course platform.
My advice for creators changing stores
Pick by what you sell, then by how you'd like to grow. If you sell a handful of downloads to an audience you've built on social, a simple store or creator page will cover you and keep things light. If teaching is the business, a course platform will save you stitching together video hosting, logins and email. If merch is the main line, a branded shop or full ecommerce platform is built for that work in a way a downloads tool isn't.
Move one product first, not your whole catalogue. Set it up, buy it yourself with a real card, and check the receipt, the delivery email and the download or login. If that journey feels clunky, your customers will feel it too. For more options, see my lists of Gumroad alternatives and Stan Store alternatives.
Questions to put to every plan page
- Does the platform take a share of each sale, and does that change between plans?
- Which payment providers can you connect, and who handles refunds?
- Is tax on digital sales handled for you, or is that on you? Rules vary by country, so check with your tax authority.
- Can you export your customer list and sales history if you leave?
- Can you use your own domain and remove the platform's branding?
Do you make store or course software for creators? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between a store builder and a course platform?
A store builder sells files, products or access and delivers them after checkout. A course platform hosts lessons, tracks progress and gives students a login, often with community features.
Can I sell digital products and merch from one place?
Some platforms handle both, others focus on one. If merch is a big part of your income, choose a tool built for physical or print-on-demand products.
Do I need my own website to sell digital products?
No. Many platforms give you a hosted store or creator page, and some let you sell from a link you share on social or by email. Your own domain helps with branding later.
Who handles tax on digital sales?
It depends on the platform and where your buyers live. Some handle it for you, others leave it to you. Requirements vary, so check with your tax authority.
How do I move my customers from one store to another?
Export your customer list and past orders before you switch, then email customers with the new links to their products. Keep the old store open until past buyers have downloaded what they need.

