Magento is now documented by Adobe under the Adobe Commerce name, with Magento Open Source still named for the open-source edition. Shopify is a hosted, all-in-one platform you can build a store on yourself, while Adobe Commerce is aimed at developers who customise and extend it, so the decision rests on who'll build and run your store.
Searching for Magento lands you on Adobe Commerce
Type Magento into a search bar and you'll mostly end up reading about Adobe Commerce. Adobe's documentation describes Adobe Commerce on Cloud, Adobe Commerce as a Cloud Service, and still names Magento Open Source for the open-source edition. Its developer page is addressed to developers, offering tools to customise and extend Adobe Commerce for multichannel, global selling to both businesses and consumers.
Shopify's page speaks to a different person. It calls itself the all-in-one commerce platform for businesses, and the first thing it offers is to build your online store instantly with AI, or with prebuilt themes. One is talking to the person who'll run the store. The other is talking to the person who'll build it.
The naming catch that trips up store owners
Here's where comparisons go off track. Plenty of articles still treat Magento as one product with one way of running it. Adobe's own docs now describe more than one route. Adobe Commerce on Cloud is described as a cloud-native, fully managed platform-as-a-service. Adobe Commerce as a Cloud Service is described as a fully managed software-as-a-service option. And Magento Open Source is still named in the technical docs for the open-source edition.
Those aren't small differences. A managed software service, a managed platform you deploy to and an open-source edition each ask very different things of your team. So when someone tells you what Magento is like to run, ask which of those they mean. And when you compare it with Shopify, compare it with the specific Adobe route you'd use, not with a general idea of Magento.
The vendor's page doesn't say much about free options for Adobe Commerce, so check Adobe's own site for what each route includes. Shopify's call to action is to start for free, which works as a trial; check Shopify's own site for how long that runs.
Shopify and Magento compared
Both in one view, in no particular order. Each description is based on what the vendor says about its own platform.
| Tool | Kind of platform | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Magento (Adobe Commerce) | Developer-led commerce platform | Developers customising and extending a store |
| Shopify | Hosted ecommerce platform | Owners building and running a store themselves |
Magento (Adobe Commerce)
Best for: Teams with developers who'll customise and extend their store, now sold by Adobe as Adobe Commerce. Vendor claim: a secure, scalable and extensible commerce platform.
Shopify
Best for: Owners building a hosted store to sell online, in person and on social. Vendor claim: sell everywhere people shop.
Three mistakes to avoid on a platform move
The first mistake is assuming Adobe Commerce is a self-serve tool you can set up over a weekend. Adobe's docs home separates developer, merchant and operations documentation, and its developer page lists API-first commerce and event-driven integrations. That's the language of a technical build, with a team behind it.
The second mistake is assuming Shopify can't go custom. Shopify has Hydrogen, which it describes as its headless commerce toolkit for custom storefronts. So a developer-built front end isn't only an Adobe Commerce option; it's worth asking whether Shopify with Hydrogen covers what your developers want.
The third mistake is comparing on store building alone and ignoring where you sell. Shopify talks about selling online and in person, across AI and on social, and it has Shopify Markets for cross-border selling and Sidekick, its built-in AI assistant, for spotting growth and automating tedious tasks. Adobe Commerce leans on Live Search, which Adobe describes as an AI-powered search tool for shoppers. List the places you sell and the jobs you want help with before you weigh the two.
Adobe pitches Live Search at consumer shoppers, promising smarter, faster and more relevant results. Shopify's AI pitch starts earlier, at the point of building the store itself. Both are useful, but they help different people: one helps your customers find things, the other helps you get the shop open and keep it running.
A trial build before any migration
Don't move a live store on the strength of a sales page. Run a small test build first:
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
- Pick a handful of real products with their photos, variants and descriptions.
- Build a test store on Shopify with a prebuilt theme, and ask your developer to spin up a test on the Adobe Commerce route you'd use.
- Connect the one or two systems you can't live without, such as stock or accounting.
- Place test orders from a phone and a laptop, and note anything that breaks or feels slow.
- Ask who'll maintain each version a year from now, and write the answer down.
That last question is often the one that decides it. A store that only one developer understands is a risk for a small business, while a store you can edit yourself but can't extend may hold you back once you grow. Be clear which of those worries you more.
Store owners, developers and agencies: where each lands
If you're a store owner who wants to build and run the shop yourself, with themes, AI help and selling across online, in-person and social channels, Shopify is built for that. If you've got developers, or an agency, who need to customise and extend the platform with API-first integrations for business and consumer selling, Adobe Commerce is aimed squarely at them, and Magento Open Source is still there for teams who want the open-source edition.
My Shopify review goes deeper on the hosted side, and Shopify alternatives and Shopify vs WooCommerce cover other routes if neither of these feels right.
Do you make ecommerce or online store software? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.
Frequently asked questions
Is Magento the same as Adobe Commerce?
Adobe now documents the platform under the Adobe Commerce name, and its technical docs still name Magento Open Source for the open-source edition. Check Adobe's own docs for which route matches what you're thinking of.
Does Shopify have a free plan?
Shopify's page invites you to start for free, which works as a trial. Check Shopify's own site for how long it runs and what's included.
Is Adobe Commerce hosted for you?
Adobe's docs describe Adobe Commerce on Cloud as a fully managed platform-as-a-service, and Adobe Commerce as a Cloud Service as a fully managed software-as-a-service option. The open-source edition is a different setup.
Can Shopify do a custom storefront?
Yes. Shopify describes Hydrogen as its headless commerce toolkit for custom storefronts, so developers can build their own front end.
Do I need a developer for Adobe Commerce?
Adobe's developer page is addressed to developers who customise and extend the platform, and its docs list API-first commerce and event-driven integrations. Plan for technical help.
Do both platforms use AI?
Both mention it. Shopify has Sidekick, its built-in commerce AI assistant, and lets you build a store with AI, while Adobe describes Live Search as an AI-powered search tool for shoppers.


