Asset 20 8 2
Does AI recommend your business? Run the free check →

Join 15,000 business owners, marketers and entrepreneurs. The Sunday newsletter you'll be annoyed only arrives once a week.

Article

MailerLite vs Sendy: Hosted Platform or Self-Hosted Script

Sendy fits a newsletter owner who's comfortable running PHP hosting and wants a one-time licence, paying Amazon SES directly for each batch of emails sent. MailerLite fits someone who wants everything hosted for them, with editors, automations, landing pages and support included in a plan billed by list size.

Sendy doesn't have a monthly plan in the usual sense. You buy a licence once, install the software on your own web server, and send through Amazon SES, paying Amazon for the emails that go out. MailerLite is the opposite arrangement: a hosted platform where the company runs the servers, the editor, the sending and the support, and you pay a plan based on the size of your list.

So this isn't really a comparison of two email tools with different buttons. It's a choice between renting a finished service and owning a piece of software you look after yourself. Once you know which of those you want, most of the other decisions fall into place.

Renting a service or owning a script

With MailerLite, the work you do is marketing work: writing newsletters, building automations, designing sign-up forms and landing pages, even putting up a simple website or selling digital products. Everything underneath, from the servers to delivery, is the company's problem.

With Sendy, you take on some of the infrastructure. It runs on standard web hosting with PHP and MySQL or MariaDB, and it connects to your own Amazon SES account for sending. You request a sending limit from Amazon and raise it as your list grows. If that sentence made you wince, that's useful information; if it sounded straightforward, Sendy's model may suit you well.

I'd be honest with yourself about who'll fix things at an awkward moment. A self-hosted tool is as reliable as the person maintaining it, and for some newsletter owners that person is happily themselves.

What MailerLite takes off your hands

MailerLite sells four plans: Free, Comfort, Power and Enterprise. Comfort sets limits on automations, forms, sites, digital products and user seats, while Power lifts every one of those to unlimited. Higher tiers include live chat alongside email support, so how quickly you can reach a person depends on your plan.

It's also kept pace with newer ways of working. MailerLite offers an MCP server that lets tools like Claude and ChatGPT manage your email marketing, and its integrations include Shopify, WooCommerce and Stripe, plus a Mailchimp connection. For a creator selling a course or a shop owner sending order follow-ups, that's a lot of ground covered without touching a server.

The breadth matters most for people whose newsletter is only one part of what they do. A podcaster with a back catalogue, a coach selling a workbook or a small shop can put the sign-up form, the landing page, the product and the follow-up emails in one account, instead of joining up four tools.

Getting started costs nothing: the Free plan comes with a modest contact allowance, a couple of user seats and a monthly email allowance, and paid plans carry a free trial that needs no credit card. The paid tiers are broken down one by one in my page on MailerLite's plans and what each includes.

What Sendy hands back to you

Sendy's appeal is control. It's a self-hosted newsletter application, so your list and your sending setup live on infrastructure you've chosen. The feature set covers what a newsletter needs: autoresponders, list segmentation, rules and webhooks, and bounces, complaints and opt-outs handled automatically in real time.

There's an agency angle too. White-labelled client accounts let you group lists as brands and give each client their own access, which suits a freelancer or small studio sending on behalf of several businesses from one installation.

Rules and webhooks are the quiet power here. They let a sign-up or an opt-out trigger something elsewhere, so a developer-minded owner can wire Sendy into other systems in whatever way suits them.

If you'd rather not do the setup yourself, Sendy offers an installation service where it handles everything for you. That removes the hardest first step, though the ongoing hosting is still yours to run.

Who pays for what on each

MailerLite's bill follows your list. Plans are priced by contact count, with monthly or yearly billing, and the tier you pick sets your limits on automations, forms and seats. As the list grows, so does the plan.

Work with me

Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?

I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.

Sendy splits the cost into pieces. There's the one-time licence, then your web hosting, then Amazon SES, which charges a small amount per batch of emails sent; Sendy's own page quotes that sending rate. There are no monthly fees tied to list size. For a large list that mails often, that structure can look very different from a hosted plan, but add up all three pieces, plus any time spent maintaining the server, before you compare. MailerLite's current figures are on its pricing page, Sendy's licence cost is on its own site, and Amazon publishes SES rates separately.

The licence and the server are part of the deal

Two lines in Sendy's FAQ are worth reading before you buy. Each licence is valid for installation on one domain, so running separate installs for different businesses needs separate licences. And updates are free only up to the next major version, which means a future major release may carry a cost if you want it.

MailerLite has its own small print, but it's the hosted kind: limits on automations, forms and seats by tier, and caps on the Free plan. The difference is who carries the responsibility. With MailerLite, the company keeps the software current. With Sendy, keeping hosting, PHP and the app itself updated is part of what you've signed up for.

Getting your list from one to the other

Moving into MailerLite, there's a migration page for bringing large lists across and help available from its success team. If you're on the older MailerLite Classic, the product guide also covers moving to the new MailerLite. Note that on the Free plan, API and MCP access is limited and doesn't include sending; sending through the API needs a paid plan.

Moving into Sendy, you can import contacts in bulk, add them through a subscribe form or its API, and carry custom fields across. The API is based on simple HTTP POST requests, and Sendy also works with Zapier, so sign-up forms elsewhere can keep feeding the list. Either way, export a clean list, warm your sending gradually on the new setup, and check that every form now points to the right place. The wider field is covered in this roundup of MailerLite alternatives.

Where the edges are

MailerLite's edges are its tiers. Comfort's limits arrive quickly for a busy creator with several forms and products, and the fullest support sits higher up. The Free plan is a good place to learn, but its contact, seat and email caps are tight for a serious newsletter.

Sendy's edges are the server and the setup. You need hosting that runs PHP and MySQL, an Amazon SES account with a sending limit approved, and the willingness to handle updates and troubleshooting. Its listed features centre on sending newsletters, not on landing pages, websites or selling products.

These edges don't disqualify either tool. Treat them as two questions to settle before you move: can you live inside MailerLite's tier limits as you grow, and do you have the time or the help to keep a Sendy installation healthy?

One weekly newsletter, set up on both

Take the newsletter you'd send this Friday. On MailerLite's Free plan, import a short test list, build the email in its editor, add a sign-up form, and set a simple automation that welcomes anyone new. Time how long it takes from sign-up to a test email in your inbox.

For Sendy, the hour looks different. Read through its hosting requirements and Amazon SES setup steps, check whether your current host runs the right versions of PHP and MySQL, and estimate what it would take to get the first send out, or whether you'd add the installation service. That planning hour tells you as much as a build would. If the Sendy checklist reads like a pleasant puzzle, the self-hosted route is probably yours. If you'd rather have spent that hour on the newsletter itself, MailerLite is built for you.

Do you make newsletter and email marketing tools? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.

Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.

Published and maintained by the Lilach Bullock team, covering marketing, AI and business growth.
Your buyers are asking AI who to use. Does it say you?

See for free whether ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google name you, and get the plan to become the answer.

Check my AI visibility →
Sundays only

Get the Sunday newsletter.

One email a week. AI experiments, marketing tactics, and the workflows Lilach is building right now in her own business.

Subscribe free

Let’s get your marketing running on AI.

Book a free 30-minute call

We figure out what you need, where AI fits in, and what working together would look like.

Book the call →

Or take the 30-second calculator

You’ll see the hours and the money quietly leaking out of your week, and the three workflows worth building first.

Take the calculator →

Or grab the free AI resource library

Prompt packs, templates, checklists, and swipe files. The exact tools I build for paying clients. Yours, free.

Get the library →
Keep reading

More from the blog.