incident.io fits a small Slack or Teams engineering team that wants to start free and add on-call as it grows. Rootly fits a young startup that wants hands-on help moving off its current pager, and it's the one of the two that also runs in Google Chat.
It's three in the morning, a checkout service is failing, and someone has to be paged, a channel has to open and a status page has to change. Both incident.io and Rootly page the right person and open a channel from your chat tool. They part ways on what they charge for, which chat tools they support and how much help they give you leaving your old pager, so pin those down first.
Before you book a demo: what to pin down
- The chat tool your responders live in: incident.io runs in Slack or Microsoft Teams, and Rootly adds Google Chat to those two.
- Whether on-call is inside the plan you're quoted or sits on top of it.
- How many responders need a paid seat, since both tools charge per user per month.
- Whether a free start matters: incident.io has a Basic tier that's free forever, while Rootly offers a free trial.
- Who moves your schedules and escalation policies, and whether old and new tools can run side by side during the switch.
- Which AI features you'd use and whether they're in the quote or extra.
- What your security review asks for, such as SCIM, audit logs or an uptime SLA, and which tier each vendor puts them on.
Each line has a different answer on each side, and the sections below go through them in turn, starting with the one that moves the bill most: how on-call is sold.
On-call: add-on or its own product
The price structures differ, and it's the difference that changes the maths most. On incident.io, the Team plan is priced per user and on-call is a per-user add-on on top of it, though on-call can also be bought as a standalone product. Rootly treats Incident Response and On-Call as two products, each with its own per-user price, so a team buying both sees two lines on the invoice.
On paper the totals can look close, but they depend on how many of your users need each part. A team where everyone declares incidents but only a few people carry the pager will land differently from one where every engineer is on the rota. Build the quote around your own rota rather than comparing headline seat prices.
incident.io in practice
incident.io is an incident response, on-call, investigations and status page platform that runs natively in Slack or Microsoft Teams. Its Basic tier is free forever and includes single-team on-call and a status page, a generous start for a small engineering team that wants to stop running incidents from a shared document.
The paid tiers add depth in steps. Team brings multi-team on-call, alerting and workflows. Pro adds custom dashboards, postmortems and private incidents for sensitive issues. Enterprise adds an uptime SLA and a customer success manager. On the AI side, it describes an AI agent and a living model of your production environment called Nexus, while investigations and root cause analysis are add-ons you choose to pay for.
The standalone on-call product is worth a look for a team that already likes the way it runs incidents and only wants a better pager. It lets you start with paging, keep your existing process for the rest, and add incident response later if the team takes to it.
Rootly in practice
Rootly is an incident response, on-call and AI SRE platform, and its Incident Response product runs in Slack, Teams or Google Chat. Its AI SRE requires Incident Response and is pitched as agents that find the cause and draft the fix. The vendor's page reports a benchmark drawn from a large set of incidents across hundreds of companies.
Enterprise adds SCIM, audit logs and the option to bring your own AI key, which matters to security teams that want model calls billed and governed under their own account. There's a Get started for free button and a public API reference, so a developer can look at what's possible before anyone talks to sales.
Because each product stands alone, a team can start with Incident Response and keep its current on-call setup, or buy On-Call first and keep its current incident process. That suits a phased move, where one part of the stack changes per quarter, better than a single big switch.
Reading the per-user quote
Both vendors bill per user per month, so the first number to work out is how many people need a paid seat: every responder on a rota, plus anyone who declares or manages incidents. Then list which products those people need, because that's where the two structures diverge. Exact figures change, so check each vendor's own pricing page with your seat count to hand.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Rootly runs a startup programme with up to half off for young companies under set limits on headcount, funding and age, and that can shift the picture for a team that qualifies. On incident.io, the question is how far the free Basic tier takes you before you'd need Team. Ask both vendors which AI features are in the quote, and whether paying yearly changes it.
Changing pagers without missing a page
Rootly says its migration team imports your schedules, escalation policies and users, then runs both tools side by side until you switch. I'd value that, because it means the old pager stays live while the new one proves itself. incident.io lists on-call with migration support, and its standalone on-call product lets you move paging across without changing the rest of your incident process on day one.
Neither vendor's page spells out every detail of a move, so treat these as questions to confirm with whichever one you pick: do overrides already scheduled for the coming weeks come across, do personal notification settings need redoing on each phone, and does custom alert routing transfer? Keep the old pager live until every rota has gone a full cycle on the new one, and ask each person on call to confirm they've received a test page.
Gaps to check with each vendor
Google Chat isn't listed among incident.io's chat tools, so a company that runs on it should confirm with them before going further. Its free tier covers single-team on-call only, so a company with several teams will reach a paid plan quickly, and AI investigations cost extra. If you'd like to see the wider field first, my guide to the best incident management software covers more options.
Rootly's free route is a trial rather than a free-forever tier, and its AI SRE can't be bought without Incident Response. The product-by-product structure gives flexibility but takes more reading to total up. And if a public status page matters to you, check what Rootly includes, or compare dedicated status page tools alongside it.
Run a practice incident before you sign
Set up both tools on their free route: incident.io on Basic and Rootly on its trial. Connect each to a test channel in your chat tool and add two or three teammates. Create a simple on-call schedule with one escalation step, then declare a practice incident with an obvious name, such as a fake checkout failure.
Watch what happens in each. Did the right person get paged? Did a channel open with the right people in it? How easy was it to post an update, mark the incident resolved and start a postmortem? Time each step and note anything you had to look up. You'll come out knowing which tool your team could run half asleep, and with the quote questions above, that's enough to decide.
Run the drill a second time with the person on call ignoring the first page. That's the only way to see the escalation step fire, and it shows how each tool tells the next person why they're being woken. Finish by posting a short customer-facing update on incident.io's status page, and ask Rootly how it handles the same step, because that's the part of an incident your customers see.
Do you make incident management or on-call tools? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.


