An encrypted suite with Drive, VPN and a password manager suits the person who wants one private account for everything, and that's Proton Mail. A leaner encrypted mail and calendar service that also scrambles subject lines suits the person who only wants private email, and that's Tuta.
Leaving Gmail or Outlook for something private? Then you've probably narrowed it to these two, and for good reason: both encrypt your mail, both run a free plan, and both sit in European countries with strict privacy law. The difference is less about security and more about scope. Proton Mail is one part of a Swiss suite that includes Drive, VPN, Pass and Calendar. Tuta is a German service that sticks to email, calendar and contacts, and does that job in a very focused way.
Swiss suite or German specialist
I'd point anyone who wants to replace a whole Google account, not just the inbox, towards Proton Mail. It's based in Switzerland, and the vendor's page claims more than a hundred million users and organisations, which tells you it isn't going anywhere soon. Zero-access encryption applies on every plan, the free one included. Its inbox blocks email trackers, so senders can't quietly see when you open their message. There are apps for iOS, Android, macOS, Windows, Linux and the web, and the top bundle, Proton Unlimited, pulls in a large storage allowance, the VPN, a password manager and cloud storage under one login.
Tuta suits the person who cares most about the mail itself. It's located in Germany, so GDPR covers it. It encrypts email headers and subject lines end to end, not only the body, which closes a gap many people don't realise exists. Tuta says it uses post-quantum cryptography, aimed at protecting today's mail against tomorrow's computers. Its desktop clients for Windows, macOS and Linux are free and open source, and the Android app is published on GitHub as well, which appeals to anyone who'd rather avoid an app store.
Neither choice is a compromise on privacy. It's a question of whether you want an ecosystem or a focused tool. If you're still weighing other names, my guide to Proton Mail alternatives covers the wider field.
What sets the free plans apart
Here's the detail people miss. Proton lists a Tuta comparison page in its own Switch from menu, so the two are openly competing for the same buyer, and both start you on a free plan with a single gigabyte of storage. But the free tiers aren't the same deal. Proton Free gives you one user and one encrypted address. Tuta Free gives you one calendar and three labels for sorting mail. Neither free plan lets you use your own domain: custom domains are paid-only on both.
That matters if you run a small business. If you want mail at your own domain, you're on a paid plan from day one whichever you choose, so compare the paid tiers rather than the free ones. On Proton, Mail Plus adds more storage, more addresses, a custom domain and priority support. On Tuta, the Revolutionary and Legend plans step up storage, extra addresses and the number of custom domains you can attach. For a wider look at running mail on your own domain, my guide to email hosting is a useful companion.
Both bill per user per month. Proton is cheaper when you pay for a year up front, and Tuta lets you pay yearly or monthly, with extra users billed per user. Once your own domain is in the picture, open each vendor's pricing page at the plan that includes it, because that tier is your true starting cost. Proton's paid plans come with a money-back guarantee window, which lowers the risk of trying the paid tier first. On Tuta, multi-user support is switched on by contacting support after you choose a plan, so a team can't set it up entirely on its own.
Do you make encrypted email and private productivity apps? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.
Frequently asked questions
Is Proton Mail or Tuta more private?
Both encrypt your mailbox so the provider can't read it, and both are based in countries with strong privacy law: Switzerland for Proton, Germany and GDPR for Tuta. The practical difference is what gets encrypted. Tuta encrypts email headers and subject lines end to end as well as the body, and says it uses post-quantum cryptography. Proton applies zero-access encryption on every plan and blocks email trackers in the inbox, which stops senders seeing when you open a message. If subject lines worry you, Tuta has the edge on paper. If tracking pixels from newsletters and sales emails bother you more, Proton's tracker blocking is the feature you'll notice every day. Keep in mind that a message you send to someone on another provider is only as private as their provider.
Can I move my Gmail inbox to Proton Mail or Tuta?
Yes, though the two handle it differently. Proton Mail has an import tool that brings across mail, calendars and contacts from Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo and Apple mail, and it offers an ongoing sync option for Gmail, so new mail keeps flowing while you switch over gradually. Tuta works from files: you export your old mailbox as EML or MBOX files and import them through Tuta's desktop clients. That's fine for a one-off move but takes more hands-on effort, and there's no ongoing sync mentioned for it. If you've got years of Gmail history and want the gentlest possible move, Proton's route is the easier one. If you're happy to make a clean break, Tuta's file import works.
Which is better for a small business with its own domain?
Start by ignoring both free plans, because neither lets you use a custom domain. Proton's Mail Plus includes one custom domain, and Proton Unlimited raises that and adds the VPN, password manager and cloud storage. Tuta's Revolutionary plan includes several custom domains and extra addresses, and Legend goes further on both. For a team, note that Tuta switches on multi-user support when you contact support after choosing a plan, while Proton bills per user per month with a saving on yearly billing. Proton makes more sense when the team also needs shared files and passwords in the same place, and Tuta when you only need private mail and calendar for a few people and want more domains for the money. Check each vendor's pricing page for the plan your headcount needs.
Can I use Proton Mail or Tuta in Apple Mail or Outlook?
With Proton, yes, through the Bridge add-on. Bridge runs on your computer and lets a desktop mail client such as Apple Mail or Outlook read and send from your Proton mailbox. That's a big plus if you're used to a particular desktop app. Tuta takes a different route. Rather than connecting third-party clients, it gives you its own desktop clients for Windows, macOS and Linux, and they're free and open source. So the question is whether you want to keep your current mail app or are happy to adopt the provider's own. If your workflow lives in Outlook rules and folders, Proton with Bridge will feel more familiar.
What do Proton Mail and Tuta give you for free?
Both free plans give you a single gigabyte of storage, which is enough for personal mail but fills quickly with attachments. Proton Free covers one user and one encrypted address, with zero-access encryption and tracker blocking included. Tuta Free gives you one calendar and three labels, with the same end-to-end encryption of headers and subject lines as its paid plans. Neither free plan supports a custom domain. I'd use the free tier as a test drive rather than a permanent home if you get a lot of mail: sign up for both, send yourself a few messages from your old account and see which app you enjoy opening. The paid tiers are where storage, addresses and domains open up.
What's a quick way to compare Proton Mail and Tuta before paying?
Create a free account on each. Send three messages from your current Gmail or Outlook to both: one plain, one with a large attachment, and one newsletter you'd normally receive. In Proton, watch whether the tracker blocking flags the newsletter, and try the Gmail import on a single label. In Tuta, export a small batch of old mail as MBOX and import it through the desktop client, timing how long it takes. Then reply from each to an outside address and check how the message looks on the other end. Finally, open the calendar in both and add a recurring event. The import you'd happily repeat for your whole mailbox, in the app you'd enjoy opening daily, is the one to choose.


