- Five questions that settle Stamped or Yotpo
- What Stamped does well for Shopify brands
- What Yotpo brings across more platforms
- How each vendor sets the bill
- Separate subscriptions add up on Stamped
- Moving reviews from one app to the other
- Where each app runs short
- An hour on both: a review request trial
- Two stores walked to a pick
Shopify brands that want reviews, loyalty and repeat-purchase tools from one Shopify-focused maker should lean towards Stamped. Stores on BigCommerce, WooCommerce, Salesforce Commerce Cloud or Magento, and anyone who'd like a free starting point or reviews that travel to Google, Meta and TikTok Shop, should lean towards Yotpo.
Where does your store run? Answer that one question and half of this comparison settles itself, because one of these apps lives on a single platform and the other spreads across several. The rest comes down to how many orders you take each month, whether you want loyalty in the same bill, and where you'd like your reviews to be seen.
Five questions that settle Stamped or Yotpo
Two smaller points can tip a close call. Stamped's support team works seven days a week, which matters if your busiest sales land on weekends. Yotpo offers Shopify Plus merchants a checkout integration that shows verified reviews and star ratings inside the native checkout. Work through these questions in order to test the answer above against your own store.
- Which platform is your store on? Stamped states it's built for Shopify and Shopify Plus merchants, so a WooCommerce, BigCommerce, Magento or Salesforce Commerce Cloud store can only shortlist Yotpo.
- How many orders do you take in a typical month? Both vendors tie their price to monthly order volume, so have that figure ready before you open either pricing page.
- Do you need reviews alone, or reviews plus loyalty and repeat purchase? Stamped sells those as separate subscriptions, while Yotpo folds loyalty and referrals into a wider platform.
- Where should your reviews appear beyond your product pages? If Google, Meta, TikTok Shop or AI assistants matter to your sales, note that Yotpo markets syndication to all of them.
- Which email, SMS and help desk tools do you already pay for? List them, then look for each one on both vendors' integration pages before you install anything.
If your answers came out as Shopify, reviews plus loyalty, and a stack built on Klaviyo or Gorgias, Stamped deserves the first trial. If they came out as another platform, a small order count or a need for reviews in shopping feeds, start with Yotpo.
What Stamped does well for Shopify brands
Stamped's pitch is narrow on purpose. The company describes its job as helping Shopify brands grow revenue through connected Repeat, Loyalty and Reviews experiences, and the reviews product itself covers photo and video reviews, questions and answers on product pages, and the emails that ask buyers for a review. In my view, serving one platform means the app only has to fit one set of store rules.
Getting started can be self-serve. Smaller and growing brands can pick up self-serve plans straight from Stamped's Shopify App listings, and monthly plans can be upgraded, downgraded or cancelled whenever you like, so a trial month isn't a long commitment. When something breaks during a Saturday sale, the support team's hours help: Stamped says it's available seven days a week, weekends and public holidays included.
Its integrations read like a common Shopify stack. Shop App, Klaviyo, Attentive and Gorgias are named on its site, so it's worth checking whether your own email, SMS and help desk tools are on that list. If you're also weighing apps that lift order value after the first sale, my guide to the best Shopify upsell apps covers that side of the repeat-purchase picture.
What Yotpo brings across more platforms
Yotpo calls itself an ecommerce platform for reviews and user generated content, loyalty and referrals, and AI visibility, and the vendor's page says more than thirty-five thousand brands trust it. The difference that matters first is reach across store platforms. On Shopify, Yotpo is an official partner and a Shopify Plus Technology Partner with a one-click install, and Shopify Plus merchants get a Checkout Review integration that shows verified reviews and star ratings inside the native checkout.
Beyond Shopify, the supported list is wide. BigCommerce and WooCommerce each have a dedicated Yotpo integration page. Salesforce Commerce Cloud is supported, with Yotpo named as a Quick Launch Program partner for reviews and visual content. Yotpo's reviews page also says it integrates natively with Salesforce Commerce Cloud, Shopify Plus and Magento. So a brand running Magento today, or planning a move between platforms, keeps the same reviews tool either way. If that move is still open, my roundup of the best ecommerce platforms is a sensible place to compare the options first.
The second difference is where reviews travel. Yotpo syndicates one set of reviews to Google, Meta and TikTok Shop, and it markets making those reviews discoverable by ChatGPT, Gemini and other AI engines. Product sampling, sold as an add-on, is there to get more reviews. And the feature table carries a Free column beside Starter, Pro and Premium, so a new store can collect its first reviews without paying.
How each vendor sets the bill
Neither price is a flat fee, so read both pricing pages with your own order numbers in hand. Stamped prices each product as its own subscription, with the level set by your monthly order volume, and it runs Repeat, Loyalty and Reviews as separate plans. Its pricing page also says every plan includes unlimited orders, so a busy month won't switch off review requests; the order count decides your band rather than capping you.
Yotpo works the other way round on its reviews plans. Starter and Pro each carry a monthly order cap, Premium and Enterprise are priced on request, and the Free column sits underneath them all. On Yotpo, you're checking which cap fits your store; on Stamped, you're checking which band. Add-ons such as product sampling sit outside the core plan, so price them separately if you want them.
Separate subscriptions add up on Stamped
I'd read Stamped's pricing page twice. Stamped sells Repeat, Loyalty and Reviews as separate subscriptions, so the fully loaded price sits far above the entry figure you'll see first. Its pricing page quotes one starting price for a single product and a much higher one for multi-product access. If your plan is to run reviews and loyalty from one Shopify-focused maker, budget for the multi-product route rather than the headline figure.
Yotpo's reviews plans start lower and come with a Free option, and it now markets AI visibility beside reviews and loyalty. That doesn't make it cheaper in every case: the caps on its lower plans and the custom pricing at the top mean a fast-growing store needs to check where its order count lands before assuming the entry plan will last.
Want AI doing the heavy lifting in your marketing?
I build the systems that handle the boring 80 percent, so you get your week back. Done properly, with the human kept in.
Do you make product review and loyalty apps? Tool makers can ask to be considered for a featured place on this list.
Moving reviews from one app to the other
Your existing reviews are the asset worth protecting, and both vendors plan for them. Stamped has an import tool in its dashboard, and its team will help with a migration if you email support. Yotpo lists reviews import as included on every plan, and its own page makes the point that switching doesn't mean leaving your review content behind.
Domains are the detail to check before you move. Stamped plans cover up to two domains, with each additional domain billed as an extra monthly charge. On Yotpo, syndication across domains is listed on Premium, and custom API setup arrives on Enterprise. A brand with several regional storefronts should price the domain side on both before it decides.
Where each app runs short
Stamped's limit is its platform. It's built for Shopify and Shopify Plus, so a store on another platform can't use it, and a brand that might leave Shopify would be choosing a new reviews tool at the same time. The separate subscriptions also mean the bill climbs each time you add Loyalty or Repeat to Reviews.
Yotpo's limit is that the extras sit higher up. Syndication across domains is a Premium item, custom API work is Enterprise, product sampling is an add-on, and the top plans don't show a public price. A store that starts free can find the features it wants are a few plans away, so read the feature table column by column.
An hour on both: a review request trial
You can run a fair trial of each in an afternoon. On a Shopify store, install Stamped from its self-serve app listing and Yotpo on its Free option. Import a small set of your existing reviews into each, then place one test order and watch for the review request email.
Now compare what you've got. Did photos and video come across in the import? Which widget looks cleaner on your phone? How easily could you rewrite the request email in your own brand voice, and did it connect to Klaviyo or your help desk? Finally, open each pricing page, find your order count, and price the full set of products you'd really use, not only reviews. That last step usually decides it.
Running a store on WooCommerce, BigCommerce, Magento or Salesforce Commerce Cloud? Skip Stamped, run the same trial on Yotpo, and spend the spare half hour checking how reviews show up in Google and Meta.
Two stores walked to a pick
Take a Shopify skincare brand with steady monthly orders that wants reviews and a loyalty programme, sends its emails through Klaviyo and answers customers in Gorgias. Stamped fits it on every count: it's built for Shopify, it sells Loyalty beside Reviews, and both of those tools appear in its integrations. The brand's next job is to price the multi-product route on Stamped's pricing page, since the two products are separate subscriptions.
Now take a homeware store running on Magento that wants its reviews to reach Google and Meta shopping listings. Stamped drops out at the first question, because it's built for Shopify and Shopify Plus only. Yotpo says it integrates natively with Magento and syndicates reviews to Google, Meta and TikTok Shop, so this store starts on Yotpo's Free option, imports its existing reviews, and checks which plan's order cap matches its month.
Want your tool on this list? Featured spots and reviews here are paid partnerships. Here's how to partner with me.


